Onside Kick Rules in NFL American Football

John Rizzo

the Onside Kick in American Football

In the dynamic world of American football, the onside kickstands as a captivating and strategic maneuver that can transform the course of a game within seconds. 

As a specialized play aimed at regaining possession, onside kicks are not only thrilling for fans but also crucial for teams looking to mount comebacks. However, these kicks are governed by a set of rules that can significantly influence their success and impact on the game. 

In this blog post, we delve into the intricacies of onside kick rules in American football, answering some of the most frequently asked questions and shedding light on their significance. So. stay focused. 

What Is the Onside Kick in American Football?

The onside kick in American football is a specialized kickoff strategy used by the kicking team when they are trailing in a game and want to regain possession of the ball quickly. 

Unlike a traditional kickoff that aims for distance, an onside kick is intentionally kicked with lower force and a unique trajectory, causing the ball to bounce and potentially be recovered by the kicking team before it travels the required 10 yards. 

Successfully executing an onside kick allows the kicking team to maintain possession and continue their offensive drive, giving them a chance to narrow the score gap. 

However, due to rule changes in recent years that have made the onside kick less favorable, teams often use this strategy sparingly and rely on alternative methods to attempt a comeback.

Football Onside Kick Rules

In American football, the onside kick is subject to specific rules that govern its execution and the ensuing play:

Kick Placement

The ball must be kicked by the kicking team from their own 35-yard line.

Formation

The kicking team must line up appropriately, with a certain number of players on each side of the kicker. The receiving team also lines up with a minimum of 8 players in the “setup zone” within 10 yards of the kickoff spot.

Kick Timing

The kicker can’t touch the ball more than once until it has traveled at least 10 yards from the kickoff spot. This prevents a quick tap and recovery by the kicking team.

Receiving Team’s Position

The receiving team must wait until the ball travels 10 yards before attempting to recover it. If they touch the ball before it reaches this distance, the kicking team is awarded the ball at that spot.

Ball Out of Bounds

If the ball goes out of bounds before traveling 10 yards, the receiving team gets possession at the spot where it went out.

Fair Catch

The receiving team has the option to call a “fair catch” during an onside kick attempt. If they do, they are protected from being hit by the kicking team until the ball hits the ground or another player. This gives the receiving team a chance to safely secure the ball.

Recovery Rules

If the kicking team successfully recovers the ball after it travels 10 yards, they gain possession at the spot of recovery. If the ball is recovered before traveling 10 yards, it’s considered an illegal touch, and the receiving team gains possession at the spot of the illegal touch.

Alternatives

Due to rule changes aimed at player safety, the success rate of onside kicks has decreased. As an alternative, teams might opt for a surprise “squib kick” that aims to bounce the ball off a receiving player, creating an opportunity for recovery. 

Additionally, some teams may attempt more traditional kickoff strategies when trailing.

Onside Kick Rules in the NFL

Onside Kick Rules in the NFL

In the NFL, the onside kick is a unique and strategic play used to regain possession of the ball during kickoffs in a more controlled manner. 

The rules for executing an onside kick are designed to balance the opportunities for both the kicking and receiving teams while ensuring player safety:

Kick Setup

The kicking team lines up with a specific number of players on each side of the kicker. The receiving team must also have a minimum of 8 players in the “setup zone,” positioned within 10 yards of the kickoff spot.

Kick Placement

The ball is kicked from the kicking team’s 35-yard line. Unlike a regular kickoff, which aims for distance, the onside kick is often executed with less force and a different trajectory to create a bouncing effect.

Kick Timing

The kicker can’t touch the ball more than once until it has traveled a minimum of 10 yards from the kickoff spot. This rule prevents the kicking team from immediately recovering the ball after a short tap.

Recovery and Touching Rules

The receiving team must wait for the ball to travel at least 10 yards before attempting to recover it. If a receiving player touches the ball before it reaches this distance, the kicking team is awarded possession at that spot.

If the ball goes out of bounds before traveling 10 yards, the receiving team gains possession at the out-of-bounds spot.

Fair Catch Option

The receiving team has the option to signal for a “fair catch.” This prevents the kicking team from hitting the receiving player until the ball hits the ground or another player. This allows the receiving team to secure the ball safely.

Recovery Success

If the kicking team successfully recovers the ball after it travels at least 10 yards, they gain possession at the spot of recovery. However, if the ball is recovered before traveling 10 yards, it’s considered an illegal touch, and the receiving team gains possession at the spot of the illegal touch.

Alternatives

Recent rule changes have made onside kicks more challenging due to safety concerns. As a result, teams have explored alternative strategies, like surprise “squib kicks” aimed at bouncing the ball off a receiving player, or opting for more traditional kickoff approaches when attempting to mount a comeback.

Evolution of Onside Kick Rules

Evolution of Onside Kick Rules

The evolution of onside kick rules in the NFL has been influenced by a desire to balance player safety, maintain the integrity of the game, and create competitive balance. 

Before recent changes, onside kicks were more predictable and often favored the receiving team due to their success rate. Here’s a brief overview of key rule changes:

Pre-2018 Rules

Prior to the 2018 season, the kicking team could overload one side of the field with players during an onside kick attempt, making it easier to recover the ball. This led to higher success rates for the kicking team, but it also increased the potential for high-speed collisions.

2018 Rule Change

In an effort to enhance player safety, the NFL introduced a rule change in 2018 that mandated that the kicking team had to have five players on each side of the ball during an onside kick. 

This reduced the advantage the kicking team had in terms of positioning and made it more challenging to execute a successful onside kick.

2020 Experiment

In an attempt to increase the chances of onside kick recoveries and provide teams with an alternative to the traditional onside kick, the NFL implemented a rule for the 2020 season that allowed teams to attempt a “fourth-and-15” play from their own 25-yard line instead of an onside kick. 

If successful, the team would retain possession. However, this rule was experimental and not retained for subsequent seasons.

Ongoing Evaluation

The NFL continues to assess the impact of onside kick rules on the game. The league aims to find a balance between maintaining competitiveness and ensuring player safety, so further rule changes could be introduced in the future.

Penalties for Violating Onside Kick Rules

Violating the rules surrounding onside kicks in American football can result in penalties that affect field position and possession. 

The specific penalties vary based on the nature of the violation and whether it was committed by the kicking team or the receiving team. Here are some potential penalties for violating onside kick rules:

Offside (Kicking Team)

If a player on the kicking team crosses the line of scrimmage before the ball is kicked, it results in an offside penalty. The receiving team can choose to accept the penalty and take the ball at the spot of the kickoff or re-kick from 5 yards further back.

Offside (Receiving Team)

If a player on the receiving team crosses the restraining line (usually 10 yards from the kickoff spot) before the ball is kicked, the kicking team can choose to have the play re-kicked or accept a penalty that gives them 5 yards from the previous spot.

Illegal Touching (Kicking Team)

If a player from the kicking team touches the ball before it has traveled 10 yards from the kickoff spot, it’s considered illegal touching. The receiving team can opt to take possession at the spot of the touch or re-kick after a 5-yard penalty.

Out of Bounds (Kicking Team)

If the ball goes out of bounds before traveling 10 yards, it’s a violation. The receiving team has the choice to take possession at the out-of-bounds spot or re-kick with a 5-yard penalty.

Unsportsmanlike Conduct

Any actions deemed unsportsmanlike, such as unnecessary roughness or taunting, can result in penalties that affect the field position of the receiving team.

Fair Catch Violation

If a player on the kicking team interferes with a receiving player who has signaled for a fair catch, it can result in a 15-yard penalty against the kicking team. This affects the receiving team’s field position after they gain possession.

Personal Fouls

Any personal fouls or unnecessary roughness penalties committed during the onside kick attempt can result in yardage penalties and potential ejections.

Re-Kick After Penalty

In some cases, if a penalty is assessed against the kicking team during the onside kick, the receiving team may choose to have the play re-kicked after the penalty yardage is marked off.

It’s important to note that the outcome of these penalties can influence possession and field position, making adherence to the rules of onside kicks crucial for both teams involved in the play.

Significance of Onside Kick Rules

Significance of Onside Kick Rules

The onside kick rules in American football hold significant implications for the outcome of games, strategy, and the balance between the kicking and receiving teams. Here are some key reasons why onside kick rules are significant:

Strategic Comebacks

Onside kicks are often attempted when a team is trailing in the game and needs to regain possession quickly to mount a comeback. The rules surrounding onside kicks can determine whether a team has a realistic chance of closing the score gap late in the game.

Dramatic Turnarounds

Successfully recovering an onside kick can lead to dramatic momentum shifts. A team that was previously trailing might suddenly gain possession in a favorable field position, altering the course of the game.

Excitement and Suspense

Onside kicks inject an element of excitement and uncertainty into games, as the outcome is far from guaranteed. Spectators are kept on edge as they anticipate the potential recovery and the ensuing plays.

Strategic Decision-Making

Coaches must make strategic decisions regarding whether to attempt an onside kick or use alternative strategies. The onside kick rules influence these decisions, as coaches consider the risk of violation penalties and the potential benefits of successful recovery.

Field Position Impact

Violating onside kick rules can result in penalties that affect field position. These penalties can have a cascading effect on subsequent plays, influencing the yardage a team must cover to score.

Player Safety Considerations

Recent rule changes have been motivated by player safety concerns, making onside kicks more challenging to execute successfully. This balance between encouraging competitive play and safeguarding player well-being highlights the rule’s significance.

Rule Adaptations

The NFL has periodically adjusted onside kick rules to balance the chances of success for both the kicking and receiving teams. These adaptations reflect the league’s commitment to maintaining a fair and engaging game.

Strategic Innovation

The difficulty of traditional onside kicks has prompted teams to innovate and develop alternative strategies, such as surprise squib kicks or unconventional kickoff formations. These adaptations showcase the evolving nature of the sport.

FAQs 

What is an onside kick in American football?

An onside kick is a kickoff strategy in American football where the kicking team intentionally tries to recover the ball themselves after kicking it, rather than kicking it deep for the receiving team to start their drive. 

It’s often employed when a team is behind and needs a quick change in possession to mount a comeback.

How does the placement of the ball work for an onside kick?

The ball is kicked from the kicking team’s 35-yard line. Unlike regular kickoffs that aim for distance, onside kicks are kicked with a different trajectory and often less force to create a bouncing effect, making it more challenging for the receiving team to predict its path.

What is the significance of the 10-yard rule?

For an onside kick to be legally recovered by the kicking team, the ball must travel a minimum of 10 yards from the kickoff spot before any player can touch it. If the ball is touched by a receiving player before it reaches this distance, it’s an illegal touch, and the receiving team gains possession at that spot.

Can the receiving team call for a fair catch during an onside kick?

Yes, the receiving team has the option to call for a “fair catch” during an onside kick attempt. This prevents the kicking team from interfering with the receiving player until the ball hits the ground or another player. It allows the receiving team to secure the ball safely.

How have recent rule changes affected onside kicks?

Recent rule changes have made onside kicks more challenging due to player safety concerns. These changes impact the success rate of traditional onside kicks, leading teams to explore alternative strategies such as surprise “squib kicks” or unconventional formations to increase their chances of recovery.

Wrapping Up

The onside kick rules in American football add a layer of complexity and excitement to the sport. 

These rules are essential for both fans and teams, as they directly influence the outcome of games and the strategies employed to gain an advantage. 

Whether it’s the intricacies of the 10-yard rule, the impact of fair catch options, or the innovative approaches emerging due to rule changes, onside kicks continue to be a captivating aspect of American football strategy that keeps fans on the edge of their seats. Best of luck. 

Photo of author

John Rizzo

I am a professional rugby player in the Washington DC-Baltimore area. I have been playing rugby for over 10 years and have had the opportunity to play in many different countries. I am also a coach for both youth and adult rugby teams. I graduated from Johns Hopkins University with a degree in Sports Management and Marketing. I am currently working on my MPA from American University and plan to pursue this career path after graduating next year. LinkedIn