What Was The Biggest Comeback In A Super Bowl Game: From Defeat to Glory

John Rizzo

Updated on:

The Biggest Comeback In A Super Bowl

Witnessing monumental comebacks in Super Bowl history is like witnessing the resilience of champions and the unraveling of football sagas etched in the collective memory of fans. 

From Tom Brady’s historic 25-point resurgence in Super Bowl LI to the Kansas City Chiefs’ electrifying 10-point turnaround in Super Bowl LIV, each comeback is a narrative of determination, strategic brilliance, and athletic prowess.  

This blog delves into the heart-stopping moments that defined these games, exploring the heroes, the decisive plays, and the emotional rollercoaster of Super Bowl comebacks. 

Join us as we revisit the gridiron battles that turned the tide, leaving an indelible mark on the legacy of the NFL.

What Was The Biggest Comeback In A Super Bowl Game

The greatest comeback in Super Bowl history occurred during Super Bowl LI between the New England Patriots and the Atlanta Falcons. In a stunning turn of events, the Patriots overcame a 25-point deficit, trailing 28-3 late in the third quarter. 

Led by quarterback Tom Brady, the Patriots orchestrated a remarkable comeback with five consecutive scoring drives in the final 20 minutes of regulation and overtime. 

Brady’s precision passing and strategic play-calling propelled the Patriots to tie the game at 28-28 by the end of regulation, forcing the first-ever overtime in Super Bowl history. 

Ultimately, the Patriots secured a historic 34-28 victory, solidifying their place in NFL history with the most significant comeback in the championship game.

Patriots’ 25-point Comeback Against the Atlanta Falcons

The Patriots’ 25-point comeback against the Atlanta Falcons in Super Bowl LI is a testament to Tom Brady’s legacy and the resilience of the New England Patriots.

Early Struggles

The Patriots were in a dire situation in the third quarter, trailing 28-3 to the Falcons. The deficit seemed insurmountable, putting Brady’s legacy on the line.

Brady’s Record-Setting Performance

Tom Brady, widely regarded as the greatest quarterback ever, rose to the occasion.

He set Super Bowl records with 446 passing yards, 62 passing attempts, and 43 completions. His leadership and precision passing became the driving force behind the comeback.

31 Unanswered Points

The Patriots, with the best regular-season record at 14-2, mounted a stunning comeback by scoring 31 unanswered points. This incredible run showcased the team’s determination and ability to perform under pressure.

James White’s Heroics

Running back James White played a crucial role in the comeback. He had two rushing touchdowns and an impressive 14 catches for 110 yards and a score. 

His versatility and performance under pressure were instrumental in turning the tide.

Late-Game Heroics

The game-tying moment came with 0:57 remaining in regulation when Brady connected with Danny Amendola for a touchdown, followed by a successful two-point conversion. 

This late-game heroics not only forced the first-ever overtime in Super Bowl history but also set the stage for the Patriots’ ultimate victory.

Overtime Triumph

In overtime, the Patriots continued their momentum. A touchdown drive led by Brady secured a 34-28 victory, completing the greatest comeback in Super Bowl history.

Brady’s Legacy and Belichick’s Praise

The comeback solidified Tom Brady’s legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. 

Even Patriots head coach Bill Belichick acknowledged the moment’s significance, stating, “Tom has had a lot of great ones. Tonight was one of them.”

In the annals of Super Bowl history, the Patriots’ 25-point comeback serves as a remarkable chapter, showcasing the team’s resilience and the unmatched skill of Tom Brady.

Kansas City Chiefs’ 10-point Comeback Against the 49ers

Kansas City Chiefs’ 10-point Comeback Against the 49ers

The Kansas City Chiefs’ 10-point comeback against the San Francisco 49ers in Super Bowl LIV marked a historic moment in the franchise’s history, led by the coaching prowess of Andy Reid and the young quarterback talent of Patrick Mahomes.

Late-Game Deficit

In the fourth quarter of Super Bowl LIV, the Chiefs found themselves trailing 20-10 against the San Francisco 49ers. The pressure was on as they faced a 10-point deficit with time running out.

Adversaries on the Sidelines

The narrative on the sidelines is worth noting, with Andy Reid, a seasoned coach with a storied career, facing off against Kyle Shanahan, the offensive coordinator for the 2016 Falcons, who experienced their own infamous collapse in the Super Bowl.

Mahomes Takes Control

At just 24 years old, Patrick Mahomes showcased his poise and skill under pressure. In the final 6 minutes and 13 seconds, Mahomes orchestrated a stunning comeback, leading the Chiefs to score 21 straight points.

Game-Changing Plays

The comeback was fueled by Mahomes’ ability to make crucial plays. He connected with key receivers, made strategic decisions, and demonstrated the athleticism that had already earned him league MVP honors.

Decisive Victory

The Chiefs’ comeback culminated in a 31-20 victory at Hard Rock Stadium in Miami. 

The win secured the franchise’s first Super Bowl title in 50 years and ended a two-decade wait for Andy Reid, who had previously lost a Super Bowl as the head coach of the Philadelphia Eagles.

End of a Drought

The victory was particularly significant for the Chiefs, ending a 50-year championship drought for the franchise. The resilience displayed in overcoming a double-digit deficit in the Super Bowl added to the historic nature of the win.

Mahomes’ Legacy

Patrick Mahomes’ performance in Super Bowl LIV further solidified his status as one of the most promising quarterbacks in the league. His ability to lead a comeback on the grandest stage emphasized his potential and set the stage for future successes.

The Kansas City Chiefs’ 10-point comeback against the San Francisco 49ers in Super Bowl LIV was a momentous achievement, marking the end of a long championship drought and securing a Super Bowl title for Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes. 

The comeback showcased the team’s resilience and the emergence of Mahomes as a generational talent.

Patriots’ 10-point Comeback Against the Seahawks

Patriots’ 10-point Comeback Against the Seahawks

The New England Patriots’ 10-point comeback against the Seattle Seahawks in Super Bowl XLIX is etched in NFL history for its dramatic climax and strategic decisions that defined the legacy of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick.

Early Struggles

The Patriots faced adversity while trailing 24-14 against the Seattle Seahawks. The game had been highly competitive, and the Seahawks seemed in control with a 10-point lead.

Brady’s Resilience

Tom Brady, known for his mental toughness, orchestrated the comeback. Despite throwing two interceptions in the game, a rarity for him in Super Bowls, Brady remained focused and determined when it mattered most.

Critical Touchdown Pass

The comeback began when Brady connected with Danny Amendola for a 4-yard touchdown pass with 7:55 remaining. This crucial score narrowed the gap, setting the stage for a thrilling finish.

Strategic Seahawks Decision

The game is also remembered by the Seahawks coaching staff for a controversial decision. 

Instead of handing the ball to the powerful Marshawn Lynch on the 1-yard line, they opted for a pass play. This decision ultimately led to one of the most memorable interceptions in Super Bowl history.

Malcolm Butler’s Game-Winning Interception

With just 20 seconds left in the game, rookie cornerback Malcolm Butler intercepted Russell Wilson’s pass at the goal line, securing the Patriots’ victory and their fourth championship in the Brady-Belichick era.

Brady’s Superb Performance

Despite early interceptions, Brady finished the game with 328 passing yards and a career-high four touchdown passes in a Super Bowl. His ability to rebound from setbacks showcased his resilience and determination.

The Culmination of a Dynasty

The victory in Super Bowl XLIX marked the Patriots’ fourth championship under the leadership of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick. It solidified their status as one of the greatest dynasties in NFL history.

In retrospect, the Patriots’ 10-point comeback against the Seahawks was a demonstration of on-field excellence and a testament to the mental fortitude and strategic acumen of Brady and Belichick. 

The game’s climax, with Butler’s interception, is forever etched in the memories of football fans as a defining moment in Super Bowl history.

Saints’ 10-point Comeback Against the Indianapolis Colts

Saints’ 10-point Comeback Against the Indianapolis Colts

The New Orleans Saints’ 10-point comeback against the Indianapolis Colts in Super Bowl XLIV was pivotal in the franchise’s history, marked by resilience, strategic plays, and a deep sense of purpose.

Early Deficit

The Saints found themselves trailing 10-0 in the first half against the Indianapolis Colts, with Matt Stover’s field goal and Peyton Manning’s touchdown pass to Pierre Garcon putting the Colts in the lead.

Motivation After Hurricane Katrina

The Saints played with a heightened sense of purpose, motivated by the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, which had devastated the New Orleans area. 

The team and the city sought solace and triumph in the face of adversity.

Bold Onside Kick

To open the second half, the Saints made a bold move by calling for an onside kick

The successful recovery of the onside kick set the tone for a comeback, demonstrating the team’s willingness to take risks to change the game’s momentum.

Crucial Drive and Touchdown

Following the onside kick recovery, the Saints drove 58 yards to the end zone, narrowing the deficit. This offensive effort showcased the team’s determination and ability to capitalize on strategic opportunities.

Defensive Excellence

The Saints’ defense played a crucial role in the comeback, managing to stymie Peyton Manning and the high-powered Colts’ offense for the rest of the game. The defensive effort was key to securing the victory.

Historic Victory

The Saints’ 31-17 triumph marked the first Super Bowl title in the franchise’s 43-year history. The win was a significant achievement for the team and a source of pride and joy for the city of New Orleans.

Drew Brees’ Superb Performance

Quarterback Drew Brees played a stellar role in the comeback, completing 32 of 39 passes for 288 yards and two touchdowns. Brees’ performance earned him the Super Bowl MVP honors, tying the Super Bowl record for completions.

Culmination of Resilience

The Saints’ comeback in Super Bowl XLIV wasn’t as dramatic as some others, but it symbolized resilience, determination, and overcoming challenges. 

The victory had profound meaning for the team and the community it represented.

In essence, the Saints’ 10-point comeback in Super Bowl XLIV was not just a football triumph but a symbol of hope and recovery for a city that had endured significant hardship. 

The combination of strategic plays, defensive excellence, and Drew Brees’ stellar performance made this comeback a memorable chapter in the history of the New Orleans Saints.


What is the biggest comeback in Super Bowl history?

The largest comeback in Super Bowl history occurred in Super Bowl LI when the New England Patriots overcame a 25-point deficit against the Atlanta Falcons, securing a remarkable 34-28 victory in overtime.

Who led the Patriots’ historic comeback in Super Bowl LI?

Tom Brady, widely regarded as one of the greatest quarterbacks, orchestrated the Patriots’ historic comeback in Super Bowl LI, showcasing his leadership and skill in a remarkable performance.

How did the Kansas City Chiefs stage a comeback in Super Bowl LIV?

In Super Bowl LIV, the Kansas City Chiefs, led by Patrick Mahomes, staged a 10-point comeback against the San Francisco 49ers in the fourth quarter, scoring 21 unanswered points to secure a 31-20 victory.

What marked the Patriots’ 10-point comeback against the Seahawks in Super Bowl XLIX?

In Super Bowl XLIX, the New England Patriots, trailing 24-14, staged a 10-point comeback against the Seattle Seahawks. 

The game is remembered for a crucial interception by Malcolm Butler in the final moments, securing the Patriots’ victory.

How did the New Orleans Saints overcome a 10-point deficit in Super Bowl XLIV?

In Super Bowl XLIV, the New Orleans Saints, motivated by Hurricane Katrina’s aftermath, overcame a 10-point deficit against the Indianapolis Colts. 

A strategic onside kick, a crucial drive, and defensive excellence led to their 31-17 victory, marking their first Super Bowl title.

Wrapping Up

In the annals of Super Bowl history, these comebacks stand as testaments to the extraordinary fortitude of athletes, the genius of coaches, and the unpredictable beauty of the game. 

From overcoming seemingly insurmountable deficits to seizing victory from the jaws of defeat, these tales inspire generations of football enthusiasts. 

Whether etched in the record books or vividly remembered by fans, the biggest comebacks in Super Bowl history showcase the indomitable spirit of champions. 

As we relive these moments, we’re reminded that in the Super Bowl arena, the game is never truly over until the final whistle, and every play has the potential to script an unforgettable chapter in the sport’s storied legacy.

Photo of author

John Rizzo

I am a professional rugby player in the Washington DC-Baltimore area. I have been playing rugby for over 10 years and have had the opportunity to play in many different countries. I am also a coach for both youth and adult rugby teams. I graduated from Johns Hopkins University with a degree in Sports Management and Marketing. I am currently working on my MPA from American University and plan to pursue this career path after graduating next year. LinkedIn