If you follow the Cincinnati Reds or remember the 2022 New York Yankees, you have probably wondered: is Jose Trevino an All-Star?
The short answer is yes. Trevino earned his first and only MLB All-Star selection in 2022, during a breakout season that also brought him a Gold Glove and the American League Platinum Glove.
That one summer changed how the baseball world saw a catcher who started the year as a little-known backup. In this post, we break down how Jose Trevino became an All-Star, why his defense made him special, what happened after his big year, and where his career stands as the 2026 season comes to a close.
Yes, Jose Trevino Is a One-Time MLB All-Star
Jose Trevino was named to the American League All-Star team on July 10, 2022, as a reserve catcher for the New York Yankees. It was the first All-Star selection of his career, and it remains his only one.
The honor carried extra meaning. Trevino became the first Oral Roberts University alum to reach an All-Star Game since pitcher Mike Moore in 1989.
He was also one of six Yankees picked that summer, joining Aaron Judge, Gerrit Cole, Nestor Cortes, Clay Holmes, and Giancarlo Stanton on one of the deepest All-Star groups in baseball.
So when fans ask whether Jose Trevino is an All-Star, the accurate answer is that he is a former All-Star. That title stays with a player for life, and Trevino earned his the hard way.
How Jose Trevino Earned His 2022 All-Star Selection
Trevino’s All-Star season began with a surprise trade. On April 2, 2022, about a week before Opening Day, the Texas Rangers sent him to the Yankees for pitchers Albert Abreu and Robby Ahlstrom. New York saw him as a defensive platoon partner for Kyle Higashioka, not as a future All-Star.
He quickly forced his way into a bigger role. Trevino handled the Yankees’ pitching staff with confidence and came through in big moments, including two walk-off hits before the break.
Going into the final game before the All-Star rosters were set, he was slashing .255/.303/.438, which is excellent production for a glove-first catcher.
By midseason, he had replaced Higashioka as New York’s primary starter. The Yankees were rolling, their pitchers were thriving, and much of the credit landed on the man calling the game. Many observers called him one of the biggest steals of the offseason in all of baseball.
Trevino finished 2022 batting .248 with 11 home runs and 43 RBIs in 115 games. Each of those last three numbers was a career high.
Elite Defense: The Real Reason Trevino Became a Star
Trevino’s bat was solid in 2022, but his glove is what made him special. He was one of the best pitch framers in the sport, turning borderline pitches into called strikes and helping his pitchers stay ahead in the count. He also excelled at blocking balls in the dirt and earning the trust of his staff.
The numbers backed up the eye test. Trevino led all MLB catchers with 21 defensive runs saved in 2022, which tied for third among all position players. After the season, the hardware piled up:
- Gold Glove Award as the best defensive catcher in the American League
- Platinum Glove Award as the best overall defender in the American League
- Fielding Bible Award at catcher
The Platinum Glove made history. Trevino became the first Yankees player, and the first American League catcher, to win it since the award began in 2011. For a player who opened the season as a backup, it capped one of the most surprising rises of the year.
From Corpus Christi to the Big Leagues
Jose Trevino was born on November 28, 1992, in Corpus Christi, Texas, and played college baseball at Oral Roberts University. The Texas Rangers selected him in the sixth round of the 2014 MLB Draft, 186th overall.
His defense stood out early. He won Minor League Gold Glove Awards at catcher in both 2016 and 2017.
Trevino made his MLB debut with the Rangers on June 15, 2018, and wasted no time making memories. He collected his first big-league hit the next day, then delivered a two-run walk-off single the day after that.
From 2018 through 2021, he moved between Triple-A and the majors, mostly as a backup in Texas. Rangers fans loved the hometown kid, but he never held a full-time job there. The trade to New York finally gave him the opportunity he had been waiting for.
Life After the All-Star Season
Trevino could not repeat his 2022 magic. In 2023, a right wrist injury bothered him for much of the year and eventually required season-ending surgery in July. His bat suffered, and there was no All-Star buzz that summer.
He returned as a Yankees starter in 2024 but split the job almost evenly with rookie Austin Wells. His throwing arm also became a weakness, highlighted by a game in which the Boston Red Sox stole nine bases with him behind the plate.
Wells soon took over, and Trevino moved into a backup role. He finished 2024 with a .215 average, eight home runs, and 28 RBIs in 74 games.
Even in those tougher years, coaches and pitchers kept praising his game-calling, framing, and leadership. Those strengths kept his value high, even as his offense dipped.
Where Is Jose Trevino Now?
Trevino now plays for the Cincinnati Reds. On December 20, 2024, the Yankees traded him to Cincinnati for reliever Fernando Cruz and catcher Alex Jackson.
The Reds liked him so much that they signed him to a contract extension in March 2025, before he had played a regular-season game for them. The deal runs through 2027, with a club option for 2028.
In 2025, Trevino worked mainly as the backup to Tyler Stephenson. He hit .238 with four home runs and 22 RBIs, though his bat faded badly in the second half.
His 2026 season has mixed setbacks with big moments. A left hamstring strain cost him time, but he returned in mid-June and soon had a three-hit game with a three-run homer against Milwaukee, followed by a two-homer game against Colorado.
In September, he lined a go-ahead, bases-loaded single against San Diego and a two-run, tiebreaking single against the Chicago Cubs. Manager Terry Francona has trusted him in key spots, especially against hard-throwing pitchers.
Could Trevino Become an All-Star Again?
A second All-Star selection would be a long shot. Trevino turns 34 in November 2026, and he now works mostly as a backup. All-Star spots usually go to everyday players with big offensive numbers, which has never been his calling card.
Still, his value goes beyond the box score. Teams prize catchers who frame pitches, call smart games, and earn a pitching staff’s trust. Those skills are exactly why the Reds traded for him and extended his contract so quickly.
Final Verdict: Is Jose Trevino an All-Star?
Yes. Jose Trevino is a 2022 MLB All-Star, and that same year he won a Gold Glove and became the first Yankee to win the Platinum Glove.
He has not returned to the Midsummer Classic since, but his breakout season remains one of the best underdog stories in recent baseball history.
Today, he brings that same veteran leadership and defensive skill to the Cincinnati Reds.
