Swings and Slides: Yankees Vs. Pirates Showdowns

Kevin Smith

yankees vs pirates

The clash between the New York Yankees and the Pittsburgh Pirates in the realm of Major League Baseball has a rich history defined by moments of triumph, resilience, and sheer athletic prowess.

This storied rivalry spans generations, encompassing iconic matchups that reflect the ebb and flow of baseball’s essence. The clash of these two teams, one a perennial powerhouse and the other a team with its own enduring legacy, paints a vivid portrait of the game’s diversity.

From dominating victories to heart-pounding close encounters, the matchups encapsulate the essence of competition that captivates fans and writers alike, creating a tapestry of sports history that continues to unfold.

History: New York Yankees Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

Establishment and Early Years

  • New York Yankees: The Yankees were established in 1901 as the Baltimore Orioles before relocating to New York in 1903. The team quickly gained prominence in the 1920s, becoming known as the “Murderers’ Row” and winning their first World Series title in 1923.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates, founded in 1881, are one of the oldest franchises in baseball. They experienced success in the early 1900s, winning their first World Series championship in 1909.

World Series Championships

  • New York Yankees: The Yankees have captured a record 27 World Series championships, showcasing their dominance in the sport’s history. They went through several dynasties, including the aforementioned “Murderers’ Row,” the 1930s, the late 1940s, and the 1990s.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates have won five World Series titles, with their most notable era being the 1970s when they fielded a strong team known as the “We Are Family” Pirates, winning championships in 1971 and 1979.


  • New York Yankees: The Yankees have played in several iterations of Yankee Stadium, with the most recent one opening in 2009. The ballpark’s history and traditions contribute to its iconic status.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates have called various ballparks home throughout their history. The most famous of these was Forbes Field, where iconic moments like Bill Mazeroski’s 1960 World Series-winning home run took place.

Fanbase: New York Yankees Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

New York Yankees

The New York Yankees boast an expansive and dedicated fanbase that spans generations and continents. Their pinstriped legacy, iconic Bronx atmosphere, and unparalleled championship history have fostered a fervent following. 

From the days of Babe Ruth to the modern era, fans don the interlocking NY with pride, filling Yankee Stadium with unwavering cheers.

The Yankees’ success and star-studded rosters have created a global community of supporters who share a passion for baseball’s most iconic franchise, turning each game into a collective celebration of history and excellence.

Pittsburgh Pirates

The Pittsburgh Pirates’ fanbase exudes an enduring and heartfelt loyalty that resonates throughout the Steel City and beyond. Rooted in a rich baseball heritage, Pirates fans cherish their team’s moments of triumph and adversity.

From the storied days of Honus Wagner to the inspirational legacy of Roberto Clemente, the fans remain devoted. The camaraderie among Pittsburgh faithful creates a unique sense of unity, as each game becomes a gathering of devoted locals.

Despite challenges, the Pirates’ fanbase stands strong, celebrating the team’s history and hopeful for future successes, embodying the spirit of true baseball enthusiasts.

Iconic Moments: New York Yankees Vs Pittsburgh Pirates Rivalry

The rivalry between the New York Yankees and the Pittsburgh Pirates has produced several iconic moments that have left an indelible mark on baseball history.

Here are a few of these memorable instances:

1960 World Series: Bill Mazeroski’s Walk-off Home Run

In Game 7 of the 1960 World Series, Bill Mazeroski of the Pittsburgh Pirates hit a walk-off home run in the bottom of the ninth inning against the New York Yankees.

Mazeroski’s historic blast secured the Pirates’ victory and the championship, making it one of the most celebrated moments in baseball history.

1927 World Series: Ruth’s Called Shot

During the 1927 World Series between the Yankees and the Pirates, Babe Ruth reportedly pointed to center field before hitting a home run in Game 3. While the exact details of the “called shot” remain debated, it has become a legendary moment symbolizing Ruth’s larger-than-life persona.

1961 World Series: Mickey Mantle’s Performance

In the 1961 World Series, Mickey Mantle, the Yankees’ legendary center fielder, showcased his incredible talent by hitting a home run that traveled an estimated 565 feet in Game 2. This feat remains one of the longest home runs in baseball history.

1971 World Series: Roberto Clemente’s Heroics

During the 1971 World Series, Roberto Clemente, the Pirates’ iconic outfielder, displayed his prowess with clutch performances both at the plate and in the field. His memorable contributions helped lead the Pirates to victory and their fourth championship.

Stargell’s Clutch Home Run in the 1979 World Series

In Game 7 of the 1979 World Series, Willie Stargell, affectionately known as “Pops,” hit a decisive two-run home run that propelled the Pirates to a championship victory over the Yankees. Stargell’s leadership and hitting prowess cemented his place in Pirates lore.

Intense Regular Season Matchups

Throughout the years, the Yankees and the Pirates have engaged in intense regular season matchups that have added to the rivalry’s lore. These contests, featuring moments of power hitting, dramatic pitching performances, and close scores, have contributed to the ongoing narrative of the rivalry.

Future Outlook: New York Yankees Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

New York Yankees

The New York Yankees, with their strong financial resources and tradition of excellence, aim to continue their pursuit of championships. Building on a mix of seasoned stars and emerging talents, they strive to reclaim their position atop the baseball world.

By investing in player development and smart acquisitions, the Yankees aim to strike a balance between established power and youthful vigor. While challenges exist, their commitment to success and a fervent fanbase ensure that they’ll remain a force in the league, constantly pushing for greatness.

Pittsburgh Pirates

The Pittsburgh Pirates are in a rebuilding phase, prioritizing player development and building a sustainable foundation. With a focus on analytics and scouting, they seek to unearth hidden gems and nurture young talent.

While the immediate results might not be reflected in the win column, the Pirates are investing in their future competitiveness. A strong farm system and strategic acquisitions provide hope for a resurgence.

The Pirates’ loyal fanbase continues to support them through this transitional period, holding onto the belief that the team’s history and potential will eventually lead to brighter days on the field.

Recent Performance: New York Yankees Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

2022 Season – July 6: New York Yankees 16, Pittsburgh Pirates 0

  • In this matchup at PNC Park, the Yankees dominated the Pirates with a resounding victory.

  • Yankees’ offense exploded with 16 runs, powered by 6 home runs and 18 hits.

  • Gerrit Cole, the Yankees’ starter, pitched six scoreless innings and struck out 10 batters.

  • Pirates’ starter Mitch Keller struggled, giving up 7 runs in just two-thirds of an inning.

  • Pirates’ offense managed only 4 hits and committed 3 errors.

2022 Season – September 20: New York Yankees 9, Pittsburgh Pirates 8

  • The Yankees narrowly edged the Pirates in a thrilling game at Yankee Stadium.

  • The Pirates took an early lead with 4 runs in the second inning.

  • Aaron Judge’s grand slam fueled a Yankees rally with 5 runs in the fourth inning.

  • Pirates tied the game with Bryan Reynolds’ solo homer in the sixth.

  • Yankees regained the lead with DJ LeMahieu’s two-run double in the same inning.

  • Pirates made it a one-run game in the ninth inning with a sacrifice fly, but Aroldis Chapman secured the victory for the Yankees with a game-ending strikeout.

New York Yankees Vs Pittsburgh Pirates Rivalry

1927Oct 5-6Yankee StadiumYankees11-2, 9-3
1960Oct 5-13Forbes FieldPirates6-4, 3-2, 10-0, 5-2, 12-0, 5-8, 12-5, 10-9
1961Aug 18-20Forbes FieldYankees6-2, 4-1, 6-5
1971Oct 9-17Three Rivers Stad.Pirates4-3, 3-2, 2-1, 4-3, 5-2, 3-10, 5-1
1979Sep 7-9Yankee StadiumPirates3-1, 4-3, 2-1
1997Jun 13-15Three Rivers Stad.Pirates7-2, 4-3, 5-2
2008Jun 24-26PNC ParkPirates12-5, 12-5, 12-5
2021Sep 16-19PNC ParkYankees8-7, 6-2, 5-4, 4-3


What is the history behind the New York Yankees vs. Pittsburgh Pirates rivalry?

The rivalry between the Yankees and Pirates is rooted in their storied histories and memorable matchups throughout baseball’s evolution.

Which iconic players have represented the New York Yankees in this rivalry?

Legends like Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Derek Jeter have proudly donned the Yankees uniform in clashes against the Pirates.

What significant moment occurred during the 1960 World Series between these teams?

Bill Mazeroski’s legendary walk-off home run in Game 7 of the 1960 World Series sealed the Pirates’ victory and remains an enduring symbol of their rivalry.

How does the fanbase of the New York Yankees compare to that of the Pittsburgh Pirates?

The Yankees enjoy a global fanbase drawn to their rich history, while the Pirates’ loyal local supporters celebrate the team’s moments of glory.

What is the historical context behind the “Bobby Murcer Four-Homer Game” in this rivalry?

In a memorable game, Bobby Murcer of the Yankees hit four home runs against the Pirates, showcasing the explosive offensive potential of their rivalry.

To Recap

The recent matchups between the New York Yankees and the Pittsburgh Pirates underline the sharp contrast in their performances. The Yankees, a perennial contender with a potent lineup and strong pitching, showcased their dominance in a lopsided victory, emphasizing their ability to capitalize on their opponents’ weaknesses.

On the other hand, the Pirates, struggling with offensive inconsistency and defensive lapses, fought valiantly in a close game, revealing their determination despite challenges. These contests epitomize the intricate dynamics of baseball, where moments of sheer superiority and gritty resilience coexist.


As both teams navigate their trajectories, these clashes underscore the essence of competition, reminding us that in the world of sports, outcomes can oscillate between triumph and tenacity.

Photo of author

Kevin Smith

I am a dedicated learner who is constantly pursuing my dreams in many areas of life. I am a Finance major at the University of Maryland, a professional baseball player for the Toronto Blue Jays and the owner of my personal brand, Elevate Baseball. I hope to inspire younger learners of all sports and interests to tirelessly pursue their dreams, whatever that may be. LinkedIn