City Showdown: the New York Mets Vs New York Yankees Rivalry

Kevin Smith

yankees vs mets

In the sprawling cityscape of New York, where dreams and ambitions converge, a unique rivalry has flourished within the realm of baseball.

The clash between the New York Mets and the New York Yankees transcends mere competition; it’s a tale of two teams that embody the spirit of a metropolis.

Since the inception of the Mets in 1962, their dynamic with the storied Yankees has evolved into a cultural phenomenon. This crosstown showdown, known as the Subway Series, has etched indelible moments into the annals of the sport.

Beyond the diamond, it’s a narrative that weaves together the history, passion, and heartbeats of two iconic franchises.

History: New York Mets Vs New York Yankees

Origins and Establishment

  • New York Yankees: The Yankees, founded in 1901 as the Baltimore Orioles, moved to New York in 1903 and became the New York Highlanders before adopting the Yankee’s name in 1913.
    The team quickly established a winning tradition, with 27 World Series championships, making them one of the most successful franchises in baseball history.

  • New York Mets: The Mets were established in 1962 as an expansion team to fill the void left by the departure of the New York Giants and Brooklyn Dodgers in 1957.
    The team’s early years were marked by struggles, but they managed to win their first World Series in 1969, known as the “Miracle Mets” season.

Success and Championships

  • New York Yankees: The Yankees’ history is punctuated by periods of dominance, including the Ruth-Gehrig era, the DiMaggio years, and the late 90s dynasty led by Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, and others.
    Their 27 championships are the most in MLB history.

  • New York Mets: The Mets experienced early struggles, but their 1969 World Series victory was a remarkable upset.
    They added another championship in 1986 behind the likes of Dwight Gooden and Darryl Strawberry.
    Despite several competitive seasons, the Mets have not reached the same level of sustained success as the Yankees.

Cultural Impact

  • New York Yankees: The Yankees’ pinstripes and iconic interlocking “NY” logo are recognizable worldwide. The team’s success and star players have contributed to their significant cultural impact, both in New York and beyond.

  • New York Mets: The Mets have a reputation for being the “blue-collar” team of New York. Their underdog victories and strong connection with their fanbase have led to a unique cultural significance, especially among working-class New Yorkers.

Fanbase: New York Mets Vs New York Yankees

New York Mets

The New York Mets fanbase is a passionate and resilient community, known for their unwavering support through highs and lows. Rooted in the team’s “Amazin’ Mets” spirit, fans at Citi Field create an electric atmosphere.

Mets enthusiasts embrace the underdog mentality, forging a close bond with players. The fanbase cherishes iconic moments like the 1969 “Miracle Mets” championship and David Wright’s era.

Their loyalty radiates beyond the ballpark, making the Mets more than a team—it’s a shared identity that unites a diverse array of New Yorkers.

New York Yankees

The New York Yankees fanbase is a storied and dedicated group that spans generations. With a legacy of 27 championships, they relish the team’s winning tradition.

Yankees fans proudly sport pinstripes, rallying behind iconic figures like Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Derek Jeter, and Mariano Rivera. The Yankees’ interlocking “NY” symbolizes excellence, drawing a worldwide following to Yankee Stadium’s hallowed ground.

Their passion and high expectations drive the team forward. The fanbase’s deep connection to history and success makes being a Yankees fan a matter of pride and a shared commitment to greatness.

Iconic Moments: York Mets Vs New York Yankees Rivalry

The rivalry between the New York Mets and the New York Yankees has produced numerous iconic moments that have left an indelible mark on baseball history.

Here are some of the most memorable moments from this storied rivalry:

Subway Series Returns (2000)

The 2000 World Series marked the first time the Mets and Yankees faced off in the Fall Classic. The city was electric as fans anticipated the matchup.

While the Yankees ultimately clinched the championship, the series showcased the intensity and excitement of the Subway Series.

Derek Jeter’s Walk-off Home Run (2005)

In a regular-season game in 2005, Derek Jeter delivered a walk-off home run against the Mets in the Subway Series. His heroics earned him the nickname “Mr.

November” and highlighted his clutch performance in high-stakes moments.

2006 Subway Series Sweep

In a three-game Subway Series matchup in 2006, the Mets swept the Yankees. This series was a defining moment for the Mets and their fans, asserting their competitiveness against their crosstown rivals.

David Wright’s Walk-off Hit (2008)

In a pivotal game during the 2008 Subway Series, David Wright hit a walk-off single, securing a victory for the Mets and providing a memorable moment for their fans.

Yankees’ Late-inning Comeback (2015)

In a Subway Series game in 2015, the Yankees staged a dramatic late-inning comeback, scoring five runs in the eighth inning to secure a thrilling victory over the Mets.

Brawl in 2000

A bench-clearing brawl during a regular-season game in 2000 added to the intense rivalry. This altercation showcased the heated emotions that often accompany matchups between these two teams.

Johan Santana’s No-hitter (2012)

Johan Santana pitched the first no-hitter in Mets history during a game against the Cardinals, adding a historic achievement to the team’s legacy.

Back-to-back Subway Series (2018)

In 2018, the Mets and Yankees faced each other in consecutive Subway Series matchups, providing fans with back-to-back weekends of intense rivalry games.

Gleyber Torres’ Four-homer Series (2019)

In a three-game series against the Orioles, Yankees’ Gleyber Torres hit four home runs, joining an elite group of players to achieve such a feat. This performance added to the excitement of the rivalry.

Pete Alonso’s Home Run Derby Win (2019)

Mets rookie Pete Alonso won the Home Run Derby during the MLB All-Star festivities in 2019, showcasing his power and energizing Mets fans.

Future Outlook: York Mets Vs New York Yankees

New York Mets

The New York Mets are poised for an exciting future with a mix of young talent and experienced players. Led by players like Pete Alonso and Jacob deGrom, the team aims to build on recent successes and contend for championships.

New ownership brings renewed energy and investment. The Mets’ strong farm system promises a pipeline of talent.

With a commitment to modernizing the organization, the Mets aim to strengthen their position in the National League East and continue captivating fans with a blend of power-hitting and dominant pitching, potentially adding new chapters to their storied history.

New York Yankees

The New York Yankees remain primed for success with a mix of established stars and emerging talent. Despite challenges, the Yankees’ legacy of excellence continues to drive their ambitions.

Key players like Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole spearhead their quest for another championship. The organization’s commitment to analytics and development fuels its long-term vision. Yankee Stadium remains a fortress of tradition and performance.

With a history of resilience, the Yankees are focused on maintaining their position as perennial contenders and showcasing their storied pinstripes on baseball’s grandest stages, aiming to add to their unrivaled championship collection.

New York Mets Vs New York Yankees Rivalry

2000Oct 21-26Yankee StadiumYankees4-1
2005June 24-26Shea StadiumYankees2-1
2006May 19-21Shea StadiumMets2-1
2008May 16-18Yankee StadiumYankees2-1
2010May 21-23Citi FieldMets2-1
2015April 24-26Yankee StadiumYankees2-1
2018June 8-10Citi FieldYankees2-1
2019July 2-4Yankee StadiumYankees2-1
2020July 18-19Citi FieldYankees2-0
2021Sep 10-12Citi FieldYankees2-1


What is the New York Mets vs. New York Yankees rivalry?

The rivalry is a historic clash between the two Major League Baseball teams based in New York City: the Mets and the Yankees.

When did the rivalry begin?

The rivalry dates back to 1962 when the Mets joined MLB as an expansion team, creating a crosstown competition with the already established Yankees.

What is the Subway Series?

The Subway Series refers to the regular interleague games between the Mets and the Yankees, symbolizing the connection between the boroughs via the city’s subway system.

How often do the teams play each other?

The Mets and Yankees play each other in a series of games every season, typically around four games (two at each team’s home stadium).

What’s the historical balance between wins for each team?

As of my last knowledge update in September 2021, the Yankees held the edge in the regular-season series, but the number of wins for each team varies from year to year.

To Recap

In the grand tapestry of baseball history, the New York Mets vs. New York Yankees rivalry stands as a captivating chapter. Spanning decades, this fierce competition has ignited the passions of fans, immortalizing moments of triumph and heartbreak.

From the Subway Series to World Series clashes, the battles between these iconic teams embody the spirit of the game. As they embark on the 2023 season with potential championship aspirations, the rivalry gains renewed intensity.

Whether you wear the blue and orange of the Mets or the pinstripes of the Yankees, the shared excitement and timeless rivalries remind us that baseball is not just a sport; it’s a woven narrative of tradition, talent, and everlasting memories.

Photo of author

Kevin Smith

I am a dedicated learner who is constantly pursuing my dreams in many areas of life. I am a Finance major at the University of Maryland, a professional baseball player for the Toronto Blue Jays and the owner of my personal brand, Elevate Baseball. I hope to inspire younger learners of all sports and interests to tirelessly pursue their dreams, whatever that may be. LinkedIn