Why Do So Many NFL Quarterbacks Come From Small Colleges: Unveiling the NFL’s Hidden Gems

John Rizzo

Updated on:

NFL Quarterbacks Come From Small Colleges

In the world of American football, the quarterback position holds a special place of prominence. These field generals are the orchestrators of the offense, responsible for making split-second decisions, delivering accurate passes, and leading their teams to victory. 

Traditionally, the NFL has been dominated by quarterbacks hailing from prestigious college football programs, such as Alabama, Ohio State, or USC.

However, in recent years, a fascinating trend has emerged, captivating fans and experts alike: an increasing number of NFL quarterbacks are emerging from small colleges.

This phenomenon has sparked curiosity and debate, prompting us to delve into the reasons behind this unexpected shift. In this article, we will explore why do so many NFL quarterbacks come from small colleges. 

Join us as we unravel the secrets behind the success of these underdog quarterbacks and shed light on the changing dynamics of the NFL.

Why Do So Many NFL Quarterbacks Come From Small Colleges?

Many NFL quarterbacks have emerged from small colleges, defying the notion that success in the league is reserved for players from larger programs. 

This phenomenon can be attributed to factors such as overlooked talent, ample opportunities to shine, system fit, and the determination of these quarterbacks.

While larger colleges dominate the spotlight, these underdogs prove that greatness can come from unexpected places. There are several reasons why many NFL quarterbacks come from small colleges:

Talent Evaluation

NFL teams primarily scout players from larger, more prominent college programs. This can lead to talented quarterbacks from smaller schools being overlooked or undervalued in the draft process. 

As a result, some of these quarterbacks may go on to have successful careers in the NFL despite not receiving as much attention during their college years.

Opportunity to Shine

Quarterbacks at smaller colleges often have more opportunities to showcase their skills and gain valuable game experience. 

They may be the focal point of their team’s offense and have more responsibility in terms of play-calling and decision-making. This can help them develop their skills and gain the necessary experience to succeed at the professional level.

System Fit

Smaller colleges may run offensive systems that are more similar to those used in the NFL. This can make the transition to the professional level smoother for quarterbacks coming from these programs. 

Additionally, quarterbacks who excel in these systems may catch the attention of NFL scouts who are looking for players with specific skill sets.

Work Ethic and Determination

Quarterbacks who come from smaller colleges often face more challenges and obstacles on their path to the NFL. 

This can instill a strong work ethic and determination in these players, as they have to work harder to prove themselves and overcome the perception that they may be less talented due to their college background. 

This drive and determination can be valuable assets in the highly competitive world of professional football.

Which College Teams Produce the Most NFL Quarterbacks?

When it comes to producing NFL quarterbacks, certain college teams have established a reputation for consistently developing and nurturing talent at the position. 

While there is no definitive list, several colleges have been known to produce a significant number of successful quarterbacks who go on to have notable careers in the NFL. 

Here are some of the college teams that have been particularly successful in developing quarterbacks for the NFL.

University of Southern California (USC)

University of Southern California (USC)

The University of Southern California, commonly known as USC, has a rich history of producing NFL quarterbacks. Notable USC alumni include Carson Palmer, Matt Leinart, and Mark Sanchez. 

These quarterbacks have achieved varying degrees of success in the NFL, with Palmer earning multiple Pro Bowl selections and Leinart winning the Heisman Trophy.

University of California, Berkeley (Cal)

Cal has also been a notable producer of NFL quarterbacks. Aaron Rodgers, a Super Bowl champion and multiple-time NFL MVP, is perhaps the most prominent quarterback to come out of Cal. 

Other notable Cal alumni include Jared Goff, who led the Los Angeles Rams to the Super Bowl, and Joe Kapp, who played in the NFL during the 1960s.

University of Miami

The University of Miami has a strong tradition of producing NFL quarterbacks. Notable alumni include Hall of Famers Jim Kelly and Vinny Testaverde, as well as Bernie Kosar and Steve Walsh. 

These quarterbacks have collectively achieved success in the NFL, with Kelly leading the Buffalo Bills to four consecutive Super Bowl appearances.

University of Florida

The University of Florida has been a consistent producer of NFL quarterbacks. Notable alumni include Heisman Trophy winner and two-time national champion Tim Tebow, as well as Rex Grossman and Danny Wuerffel. 

While Tebow’s NFL career was relatively short-lived, Grossman led the Chicago Bears to a Super Bowl appearance.

Stanford University

Stanford University has gained recognition for producing successful NFL quarterbacks. Andrew Luck, a former Stanford quarterback, was the first overall pick in the 2012 NFL Draft and had a promising career before retiring early due to injuries. Other notable Stanford alumni include John Elway, Jim Plunkett, and Kevin Hogan.

How Do Small College Quarterbacks Go Pro?

Small College Quarterbacks Go Pro

Small college quarterbacks face unique challenges in their journey to the professional level, but with the right approach and opportunities, they can still make it to the NFL. Here are some ways small college quarterbacks can go pro:

Stand Out in College

To catch the attention of NFL scouts, small college quarterbacks need to excel on the field. They should strive to be the best player on their team and in their conference. 

By consistently performing at a high level, they can generate buzz and attract the attention of talent evaluators.

Attend Showcases and Camps

Small college quarterbacks can increase their exposure by attending showcases and camps specifically designed for NFL prospects. 

These events provide opportunities to showcase their skills in front of scouts, coaches, and talent evaluators. It’s crucial to perform well in these settings to leave a lasting impression.

Seek Guidance from Experienced Coaches

Working with experienced coaches who have connections in the football world can be invaluable for small college quarterbacks. 

These coaches can provide guidance on improving skills, understanding the nuances of the game, and navigating the path to the NFL. They may also have connections with scouts or coaches at higher levels of football.

Utilize Film and Statistics

Small college quarterbacks should ensure they have high-quality game films and statistics that highlight their abilities. This allows scouts and coaches to evaluate their performance and potential. 

Sharing film and statistics with NFL teams, agents, and other influential individuals in the football industry can help generate interest and opportunities.

Participate in All-Star Games and Postseason Events

All-Star games and postseason events, such as the Senior Bowl or the NFLPA Collegiate Bowl, provide small college quarterbacks with a chance to compete against players from larger programs. 

These events attract NFL scouts and provide a platform to showcase skills and compete at a higher level of competition.

Pro Day and Private Workouts

Small college quarterbacks should take advantage of their college’s Pro Day, where NFL scouts visit to evaluate prospects. It’s crucial to perform well in drills, showcase arm strength, accuracy, and athleticism. 

Additionally, private workouts arranged with individual teams can provide further opportunities to impress scouts and decision-makers.

Consider Alternative Routes

If the traditional NFL draft route doesn’t work out, small college quarterbacks can explore alternative paths to the professional level. 

This may include signing with a team as an undrafted free agent, joining a professional league like the CFL or XFL, or participating in tryouts for arena football or international leagues.

 These opportunities can provide a platform to showcase skills and potentially earn a spot in the NFL in the future.

Ultimately, small college quarterbacks must remain dedicated, work hard, and seize every opportunity to showcase their abilities. With perseverance, talent, and a bit of luck, they can overcome the challenges and make their dreams of playing in the NFL a reality.

Best Small-College Quarterbacks in NFL History

While the NFL has seen numerous successful quarterbacks emerge from small colleges, here are some of the best small-college quarterbacks in NFL history:

Kurt Warner (Northern Iowa)

Kurt Warner (Northern Iowa)

Kurt Warner is perhaps the most notable small-college quarterback in NFL history. After going undrafted, Warner played in the Arena Football League and NFL Europe before finding success with the St. Louis Rams. 

He led the Rams to two Super Bowl appearances, winning one, and was a two-time NFL MVP. Warner’s journey from Northern Iowa to the Hall of Fame is a testament to his talent and perseverance.

Joe Flacco (Delaware)

Joe Flacco, a product of the University of Delaware, had a successful NFL career. He led the Baltimore Ravens to a Super Bowl victory in 2013 and was named the game’s MVP. 

Flacco holds several postseason records, including the most touchdown passes in a single postseason. His strong arm and ability to perform in big moments made him a respected quarterback in the league.

Tony Romo (Eastern Illinois)

Tony Romo, who played college football at Eastern Illinois, had a successful career with the Dallas Cowboys. 

Despite going undrafted, Romo became the Cowboys’ starting quarterback and earned four Pro Bowl selections. He holds numerous franchise records and was known for his ability to make clutch plays.

Steve McNair (Alcorn State)

Steve McNair, hailing from Alcorn State, had a notable NFL career primarily with the Tennessee Titans. He was a three-time Pro Bowler and shared the NFL MVP award in 2003. McNair led the Titans to a Super Bowl appearance and was known for his toughness and ability to extend plays.

Doug Williams (Grambling State)

Doug Williams, a standout at Grambling State, had a historic NFL career. He became the first African-American quarterback to start and win a Super Bowl, leading the Washington Redskins to victory in Super Bowl XXII. 

Williams’ performance in that game, where he threw for four touchdowns in a single quarter, remains legendary.

Phil Simms (Morehead State)

Phil Simms, who played college football at Morehead State, had a successful career with the New York Giants. 

He led the Giants to two Super Bowl victories and was named the MVP of Super Bowl XXI. Simms was known for his accuracy and ability to perform in big games.

Rich Gannon (Delaware)

Rich Gannon, another product of the University of Delaware, had a successful NFL career primarily with the Oakland Raiders. 

He was a four-time Pro Bowler and was named the NFL MVP in 2002. Gannon’s ability to read defenses and his leadership skills made him a respected quarterback in the league.

These quarterbacks, among others, have proven that talent can emerge from small colleges and achieve great success in the NFL. Their accomplishments serve as inspiration for aspiring quarterbacks from smaller programs.

FAQs

Are small college quarterbacks more overlooked in the NFL draft process?

Yes, small college quarterbacks often face more challenges in the NFL draft process. They may receive less attention from scouts and talent evaluators compared to quarterbacks from larger programs. 

Do small college quarterbacks have fewer opportunities to showcase their skills?

In some cases, small college quarterbacks may have fewer opportunities to showcase their skills on a national stage. They may not have the same level of media exposure or play in high-profile games. However, they often have more responsibility for their college teams’ offenses.

Do small college quarterbacks have a better chance of fitting into NFL offensive systems?

Small college quarterbacks may have a better chance of fitting into NFL offensive systems due to the similarities in play style and schemes. 

Some smaller colleges run offenses that closely resemble those used in the NFL, making the transition smoother for quarterbacks coming from these programs.

Are small college quarterbacks more determined to succeed in the NFL?

Small college quarterbacks often face more obstacles and challenges on their path to the NFL. This can instill a strong work ethic and determination in these players, as they have to work harder to prove themselves and overcome the perception that they may be less talented due to their college background. 

Are there successful NFL quarterbacks from larger college programs as well?

Absolutely. While many successful NFL quarterbacks have come from small colleges, there are also numerous successful quarterbacks who have come from larger programs. Colleges like Alabama, Ohio State, and Clemson have produced highly successful quarterbacks who have excelled in the NFL.

Signing Out

As we conclude our exploration into why so many NFL quarterbacks come from small colleges, it becomes evident that talent can emerge from unexpected places. 

The days of overlooking quarterbacks from smaller programs are fading, as teams and scouts recognize the potential and unique skill sets these players bring to the table. 

The success stories of quarterbacks like Ben Roethlisberger, Tony Romo, and Carson Wentz have shattered the notion that only quarterbacks from powerhouse programs can thrive in the NFL.

The evolving landscape of college football, advancements in scouting techniques, and the increasing emphasis on individual player development have all played a role in leveling the playing field for quarterbacks from small colleges. 

As the NFL continues to evolve, it is likely that we will witness more hidden gems emerging from unexpected places, captivating fans and challenging the traditional narratives surrounding quarterback talent. 

Photo of author

John Rizzo

I am a professional rugby player in the Washington DC-Baltimore area. I have been playing rugby for over 10 years and have had the opportunity to play in many different countries. I am also a coach for both youth and adult rugby teams. I graduated from Johns Hopkins University with a degree in Sports Management and Marketing. I am currently working on my MPA from American University and plan to pursue this career path after graduating next year. LinkedIn