Battle of Ohio: Cincinnati Reds Vs. Cleveland Guardians Rivalry

Kevin Smith

reds vs guardians

The rivalry between the Cincinnati Reds and the Cleveland Guardians (formerly known as the Cleveland Indians) is a storied and passionate competition that has captivated baseball fans for generations.

Both teams, hailing from the state of Ohio, have a rich history and iconic moments that have contributed to the intensity of their matchups.

From World Series clashes to regular-season showdowns during interleague play, the Reds-Guardians rivalry has showcased the best of baseball and fostered a sense of camaraderie and competition between the two cities.

With passionate fan bases and a legacy of memorable encounters, this rivalry continues to be a cherished part of Major League Baseball’s history.

History: Cincinnati Reds Vs Cleveland Guardians

Founding and Early Years

  • Cincinnati Reds: The Reds were founded in 1881 and are one of the oldest professional baseball teams in the United States. They were members of the American Association and later joined the National League in 1890.

  • Cleveland Guardians: The Guardians have a history dating back to 1901 when they were established as one of the original eight American League franchises.
    They were originally named the Cleveland Bluebirds, then became the Cleveland Naps before adopting the name “Indians” in 1915.

World Series Championships

  • Cincinnati Reds: The Reds have won the World Series five times (as of September 2021). They claimed titles in 1919, 1940, 1975, 1976, and 1990.

  • Cleveland Guardians: As of September 2021, the Guardians had won the World Series twice. They were victorious in 1920 and 1948, ending a 28-year championship drought at the time.

Fanbase: Cincinnati Reds Vs Cleveland Guardians

Cincinnati Reds

The Cincinnati Reds fanbase, often referred to as “Reds Nation,” is renowned for its loyalty and enthusiasm. The team’s history dates back to the late 19th century, making them one of the oldest franchises in Major League Baseball.

Over the years, the Reds have had periods of success, winning multiple World Series titles and division championships, which has further solidified the dedication of their fanbase.

The Reds’ home stadium, Great American Ball Park, is known for its vibrant atmosphere during home games.

Reds fans turn out in large numbers, wearing their team’s signature colors of red and white and passionately cheering on their players.

The team’s Hall of Fame players, such as Johnny Bench, Joe Morgan, and Pete Rose, remain revered by the fanbase, with their legacies celebrated and passed down through generations.

Cleveland Guardians

The Cleveland Guardians’ fanbase, often referred to as the “Tribe,” is equally devoted to their team. The franchise has a storied history, dating back to its founding in 1901 as one of the original American League teams.

Throughout the years, the Guardians have had their share of success, including multiple playoff appearances and World Series victories.

Guardians fans have shown remarkable loyalty and resilience, supporting their team through both highs and lows.

The team’s home stadium, Progressive Field, has witnessed moments of immense excitement and camaraderie as the fans come together to cheer on their beloved Guardians.

Iconic Moments: Cincinnati Reds Vs Cleveland Guardians Rivalry

1975 World Series – Game 6

One of the most iconic moments in the Reds vs. Guardians rivalry occurred during the 1975 World Series. In Game 6, with the Reds leading the series 3-2, the Guardians staged a dramatic comeback in the bottom of the eighth inning, tying the game at 6-6.

The game then went into extra innings, where Reds catcher Johnny Bench hit a solo home run in the top of the 10th inning, giving the Reds a crucial lead.

The Reds held on to win the game 7-6, securing their first World Series title since 1940.

Pete Rose’s Hit Record

On September 11, 1985, while playing for the Reds, Pete Rose achieved one of the most iconic milestones in baseball history.
In a game against the Guardians at Riverfront Stadium in Cincinnati, Rose collected his 4,192nd hit, surpassing Ty Cobb’s record for the most hits in MLB history.

This historic moment solidified Rose’s status as one of the game’s greatest players and added to the lore of the Reds-Guardians rivalry.

Jim Thome’s 500th Home Run

On September 16, 2007, while playing for the Guardians, Jim Thome hit his 500th career home run against the Reds at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati.

Thome became the 23rd player in MLB history to reach this milestone. His achievement added another chapter to the storied rivalry between the two teams.

Griffey Jr.’s Return to Seattle

While not directly related to the Reds-Guardians rivalry, Ken Griffey Jr., a Cincinnati Reds legend, returned to Seattle as a member of the Guardians on June 23, 2007.

The game held significant emotional value for both fan bases, as Griffey Jr. had become a beloved player during his time with the Seattle Mariners. The matchup highlighted the enduring impact of players who had played for both franchises.

Intense Interleague Battles

Since interleague play began in 1997, the Reds and the Guardians have faced each other in intense regular-season matchups. These games have provided memorable moments and heightened the rivalry’s intensity, particularly given the shared proximity of their fan bases.

Future Outlook: Cincinnati Reds Vs Cleveland Guardians

Cincinnati Reds

Their success will largely depend on bolstering their pitching staff, especially their bullpen. If their young pitchers, like Hunter Greene, can continue to develop and provide quality performances, it could strengthen their rotation.

The Reds’ offense, led by Joey Votto, Nick Castellanos, and Jesse Winker, remains potent, and if they can maintain their production while getting support from other players, the team’s overall offensive output can be formidable.

The Reds’ front office will also need to make smart moves in free agency and trades to address their pitching needs and create a more well-rounded roster.

Cleveland Guardians

Improving their offense is a top priority. They struggled in 2022, ranking last in several offensive categories.

If their young hitters, like Bradley Zimmer and Nolan Jones, can step up and provide consistent production, it could significantly boost the team’s scoring capabilities.

The Guardians’ pitching staff, led by Shane Bieber, has the potential to be a strong point, and they’ll be counting on Bieber to maintain his ace-like form.

The Guardians’ focus on player development and their prospects’ progression could be key to their future success.

Recent Performance: Cincinnati Reds Vs Cleveland Guardians

April 12-15, 2021 (Great American Ball Park)

  • Game 1: Cincinnati Reds won 6-3

  • Game 2: Cincinnati Reds won 3-1 (10 innings)

  • Game 3: Cincinnati Reds won 4-3

  • Game 4: Cleveland Guardians won 7-3

May 16-18, 2021 (Progressive Field)

  • Game 1: Cincinnati Reds won 5-4 (10 innings)

  • Game 2: Cincinnati Reds won 12-2

  • Game 3: Cincinnati Reds won 3-2

Cincinnati Reds Vs Cleveland Guardians

1975Oct 21Fenway Park (Game 7)CincinnatiReds 4-3
1994Jun 24Jacobs FieldClevelandGuardians 9-1
1995Jul 19Riverfront StadiumClevelandGuardians 5-2
1999Jun 12Jacobs FieldCincinnatiReds 5-3
2001Jul 1Great American Ball ParkClevelandGuardians 9-1
2007Jun 23Safeco FieldCincinnatiReds 16-1
2011Jul 4Progressive FieldCincinnatiReds 3-0
2016May 18Great American Ball ParkClevelandGuardians 4-3
2018Jul 9Progressive FieldClevelandGuardians 5-4


When did the Cincinnati Reds vs. Cleveland Guardians rivalry begin?

The rivalry between the Cincinnati Reds and the Cleveland Guardians (formerly known as the Cleveland Indians) can be traced back to the introduction of interleague play in 1997, providing a platform for these Ohio teams to face each other regularly during the regular season.

What is the significance of the 1975 World Series in the rivalry’s history?

The 1975 World Series was a pivotal moment in the Reds-Guardians rivalry. The Reds defeated the Guardians in a thrilling seven-game series, solidifying their status as one of the premier matchups in baseball history.

How do fans of both teams contribute to the rivalry’s intensity?

Fans of the Cincinnati Reds and the Cleveland Guardians are known for their passion and loyalty. During matchups, their spirited presence in the stadiums adds to the rivalry’s excitement and fuels the competitive spirit on the field.

Which iconic players have represented both the Reds and the Guardians?

Players like Pete Rose and Ken Griffey Jr. are among the iconic figures who have played for both teams during their careers. Their presence on both sides of the rivalry has added unique dimensions to the matchups.

What role does interleague play serve in the Reds-Guardians rivalry?

Interleague play allows these teams to compete against each other regularly, even though they belong to different leagues. These matchups provide fans with the opportunity to witness exciting games between in-state rivals, intensifying the rivalry.

To Recap

The rivalry between the Cincinnati Reds and the Cleveland Guardians is a storied and passionate competition that has endured for decades.

With a rich history, iconic moments, and dedicated fan bases, their matchups have become legendary in baseball lore.

From historic World Series battles to intense regular-season clashes, both teams have left an indelible mark on the sport and the hearts of their supporters.

As the rivalry continues to evolve through interleague play and shared legends, it remains a celebrated part of Ohio’s baseball culture.

With a profound impact on the game and enduring fan enthusiasm, the Reds-Guardians rivalry continues to captivate and inspire baseball enthusiasts.

Photo of author

Kevin Smith

I am a dedicated learner who is constantly pursuing my dreams in many areas of life. I am a Finance major at the University of Maryland, a professional baseball player for the Toronto Blue Jays and the owner of my personal brand, Elevate Baseball. I hope to inspire younger learners of all sports and interests to tirelessly pursue their dreams, whatever that may be. LinkedIn