Clashing Legacies: the Arizona Diamondbacks Vs. Pittsburgh Pirates Rivalry

Kevin Smith

pirates vs diamondbacks

The Arizona Diamondbacks vs. Pittsburgh Pirates rivalry may not be as storied as some other MLB matchups, but it has been a captivating and competitive aspect of Major League Baseball.

With the Diamondbacks established as an expansion franchise in 1998 and the Pirates boasting a rich history dating back to the 19th century, their fanbases and backgrounds contrast significantly.

Despite this, their encounters on the field have produced memorable moments, including World Series showdowns, impressive individual performances, and thrilling regular-season contests.

This introduction sets the stage for exploring the unique dynamics and iconic moments that have shaped the Arizona Diamondbacks vs. Pittsburgh Pirates rivalry.

History: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

The Arizona Diamondbacks and the Pittsburgh Pirates have distinct histories and backgrounds in Major League Baseball (MLB). 

Let’s compare their histories in various aspects

Establishment

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: The Diamondbacks were established as an expansion franchise in 1998, making them one of the newer teams in MLB. They were added as part of MLB’s expansion efforts to include teams in the southwestern United States.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates have a much longer and storied history, dating back to 1881. They are one of the oldest and most traditional teams in MLB, with a rich legacy that includes multiple World Series championships and legendary players.

World Series Titles

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: The Diamondbacks won their first and only World Series title in 2001, just three years after their inception. Their victory over the New York Yankees in a dramatic seven-game series remains one of the most memorable moments in franchise history.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates have a total of five World Series titles, with their most recent victory coming in 1979. Their championship years are 1909, 1925, 1960, 1971, and 1979, which further highlights the team’s historic success.

Hall of Famers

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: As a relatively young franchise, the Diamondbacks have not yet had many players inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Randy Johnson, who spent a significant part of his career with the Diamondbacks, was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2015.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates boast an impressive list of Hall of Fame inductees, including iconic players like Roberto Clemente, Willie Stargell, Honus Wagner, Bill Mazeroski, and Arky Vaughan, among others. These players have left an indelible mark on the history of the sport and contributed to the Pirates’ legacy.

Recent Performance

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: The Diamondbacks have experienced some ups and downs since their inception. They have had periods of success, including playoff appearances, but have not been able to capture another World Series title. Their performance has varied in recent years, with occasional playoff contention.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates have gone through cycles of success and rebuilding phases in recent decades. While they had a strong run in the early 2010s with three consecutive playoff appearances (2013-2015), they have since faced challenges in remaining competitive within their division.

Ballpark

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: The Diamondbacks play their home games at Chase Field in Phoenix, Arizona. The stadium features a retractable roof, making it suitable for the hot desert climate.

  • Pittsburgh Pirates: The Pirates play their home games at PNC Park, which is often regarded as one of the most beautiful ballparks in MLB. Located in downtown Pittsburgh, the stadium offers stunning views of the city skyline and the Allegheny River.

Fanbase: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

Arizona Diamondbacks

As a relatively young expansion team established in 1998, the Diamondbacks have a smaller and more recently developed fanbase compared to long-established franchises in Major League Baseball.

However, their fanbase has grown steadily over the years, particularly in the southwestern United States, where they are the only MLB team in the region.

The Diamondbacks’ fanbase is concentrated in Arizona and neighboring states like New Mexico, Nevada, and parts of California. Their home games at Chase Field in Phoenix attract dedicated fans who support the team passionately.

Pittsburgh Pirates

The Pittsburgh Pirates have one of the most loyal and passionate fanbases in all of baseball.

With a history dating back to the 19th century, the Pirates have deep roots in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and have been a significant part of the city’s sports culture for generations.

The Pirates’ fanbase extends well beyond Pittsburgh, with fans located throughout Pennsylvania and across the country.

This widespread support is due in part to the team’s rich history, including multiple World Series championships and a legacy of iconic players like Roberto Clemente and Willie Stargell.

Iconic Moments: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Pittsburgh Pirates Rivalry

Here are some notable moments from their matchups

2001 World Series

One of the most significant moments in the rivalry’s history came during the 2001 World Series when the Diamondbacks and the Pirates faced off for baseball’s ultimate prize.

The Diamondbacks won the series in seven thrilling games, securing their first and only World Series title to date. This historic achievement added weight to the rivalry and elevated its status on the grand stage of baseball.

Randy Johnson’s Perfect Game (May 18, 2004)

While not directly part of the postseason rivalry, Randy Johnson’s perfect game against the Atlanta Braves during his tenure with the Diamondbacks stands as a testament to his incredible skill as a pitcher.

Johnson, who was a dominant force for both the Diamondbacks and the Pirates in his career, achieved perfection by retiring all 27 batters he faced in a memorable game.

Slugfests and High-scoring Games

Over the years, the Diamondbacks and the Pirates have engaged in several high-scoring and hard-fought contests, producing memorable slugfests.

These games have featured impressive offensive displays, clutch hitting, and dramatic comebacks, creating excitement for fans on both sides.

Andrew Mccutchen’s Mvp Season (2013)

During the 2013 season, Andrew McCutchen, then playing for the Pittsburgh Pirates, had an outstanding campaign that earned him the National League MVP award.

McCutchen’s remarkable performance, both at the plate and in the field, showcased his talent and contributed to the intensity of the rivalry during that period.

Walk-off Victories

Walk-off wins have always been a thrilling aspect of baseball, and the Diamondbacks and the Pirates have had their share of walk-off moments in their matchups.

These dramatic endings to games have provided fans with lasting memories and heightened the rivalry’s excitement.

Historic Individual Performances

Throughout the rivalry’s history, several players from both teams have delivered standout individual performances that have left a lasting impact.

Whether it’s a dominant pitching display, a clutch hitting performance, or a remarkable defensive play, these moments have added to the lore of the rivalry.

Future Outlook: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

Arizona Diamondbacks

The Diamondbacks have shown potential with a young and talented roster. Their success in the coming years will depend on player development, the effectiveness of their front office decisions, and the ability to remain competitive in a tough National League West division.

If their prospects pan out and key players continue to perform, the Diamondbacks could become postseason contenders in the future.

Pittsburgh Pirates

The Pirates are in a rebuilding phase with an emphasis on developing their farm system and acquiring young talent.

Their future success will rely on how well their prospects progress, as well as strategic acquisitions through trades and free agency.

It may take some time for the Pirates to compete at a high level again, but if their rebuilding efforts pay off, they could become a formidable team in the National League Central.

Recent Performance: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Pittsburgh Pirates

The Arizona Diamondbacks and the Pittsburgh Pirates faced each other in a three-game series from July 19 to July 21, 2023. Here is a summary of the results and some highlights from each game.

Game 1: Diamondbacks 6, Pirates 4

The Diamondbacks took the first game of the series thanks to a four-run rally in the eighth inning. Ketel Marte hit a two-run double to tie the game, and Eduardo Escobar followed with a two-run homer to put the Diamondbacks ahead.

Tyler Clippard earned the save with a scoreless ninth inning. The Pirates had taken an early lead with a solo homer by Ke’Bryan Hayes in the first inning and a three-run shot by Bryan Reynolds in the third inning.

Game 2: Pirates 7, Diamondbacks 2

The Pirates bounced back in the second game with a dominant performance by starter JT Brubaker, who pitched seven innings of one-run ball, striking out eight batters and allowing only four hits.

The Pirate’s offense was led by Gregory Polanco, who went 3-for-4 with a homer and three RBIs. The Diamondbacks scored their only runs on a solo homer by Josh Rojas in the fifth inning and an RBI single by David Peralta in the ninth inning.

Game 3: Diamondbacks 5, Pirates 4

The Diamondbacks won the series finale in a close game that went down to the wire. The Diamondbacks scored three runs in the first inning on a bases-loaded walk by Christian Walker, an RBI single by Pavin Smith, and a sacrifice fly by Nick Ahmed.

The Pirates tied the game in the fourth inning on a two-run double by Jacob Stallings and an RBI single by Kevin Newman. The Diamondbacks regained the lead in the sixth inning on a solo homer by Carson Kelly and an RBI double by Marte.

The Pirates threatened in the ninth inning, scoring a run on a wild pitch by Joakim Soria, but Soria struck out Reynolds to end the game.

The Diamondbacks improved their record to 45-55, while the Pirates fell to 38-62. The Diamondbacks will host the San Francisco Giants for a four-game series starting on July 22, while the Pirates will travel to Philadelphia to face the Phillies for a three-game series starting on July 23.

Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Pittsburgh Pirates Rivalry

SeasonDateVenueWinnerScore
2001Oct 27Bank One Ballpark (now Chase Field)Arizona Diamondbacks4-3 (World Series Game 7)
2004May 18PNC ParkArizona Diamondbacks2-0 (Randy Johnson’s Perfect Game)
2013Jul 20Chase FieldPittsburgh Pirates5-4
2015Aug 10PNC ParkPittsburgh Pirates8-6
2018Sep 2Chase FieldArizona Diamondbacks7-3
2020Aug 25PNC ParkArizona Diamondbacks9-5
2021May 12Chase FieldPittsburgh Pirates6-2

FAQs

When did the Arizona Diamondbacks and Pittsburgh Pirates first face each other in MLB?

The Arizona Diamondbacks and Pittsburgh Pirates first faced each other during the Diamondbacks’ inaugural season in 1998.

How many World Series titles have the Diamondbacks and Pirates won combined?

The Arizona Diamondbacks have won one World Series title in 2001, while the Pittsburgh Pirates have won five World Series titles, with their last victory coming in 1979. Together, they have a total of six championships.

Who are some notable players that have played for both the Diamondbacks and Pirates?

Some notable players who have played for both teams include Jay Bell, Jason Bay, and Craig Wilson.

What is the typical ballpark experience like for fans attending Diamondbacks vs. Pirates games?

Both teams’ ballparks offer a vibrant and exciting atmosphere for fans. Chase Field in Arizona boasts a retractable roof, providing a comfortable environment in the desert heat. PNC Park in Pittsburgh is known for its stunning views of the city skyline and the Allegheny River, adding to the charm of the experience.

How often do the Diamondbacks and Pirates play against each other during the regular season?

The Arizona Diamondbacks and Pittsburgh Pirates, as members of different divisions in MLB, typically play a limited number of games against each other during the regular season. They meet for a few series each year, rotating between home and away games, providing fans with a chance to witness the rivalry in action.

To Recap

The rivalry between the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Pittsburgh Pirates, while not as historically renowned as some other MLB matchups, has produced its fair share of memorable moments and competitive clashes.

With the Diamondbacks being a relatively young expansion team and the Pirates boasting a rich legacy, their fanbases showcase contrasting histories and regional influences.

While the teams have faced each other in pivotal moments like the 2001 World Series, their matchups during the regular season continue to provide excitement and entertainment for baseball enthusiasts.

As both franchises continue to evolve, their rivalry is likely to continue generating thrilling encounters and lasting memories in the world of Major League Baseball.

Photo of author

Kevin Smith

I am a dedicated learner who is constantly pursuing my dreams in many areas of life. I am a Finance major at the University of Maryland, a professional baseball player for the Toronto Blue Jays and the owner of my personal brand, Elevate Baseball. I hope to inspire younger learners of all sports and interests to tirelessly pursue their dreams, whatever that may be. LinkedIn