The San Francisco 49ers have had a long and storied history of great quarterbacks, from Joe Montana and Steve Young to Jeff Garcia and Colin Kaepernick.
But in recent years, the team has struggled to find a consistent and healthy signal-caller who can lead them to success.
Since 2017, the 49ers have started seven different quarterbacks: Brian Hoyer, C.J. Beathard, Jimmy Garoppolo, Nick Mullens, Trey Lance, Nate Sudfeld and Josh Rosen.
None of them have played a full 16-game season for the team, and only Garoppolo has led them to the playoffs.
The 49ers have also suffered a series of unfortunate injuries at the QB position, most notably Garoppolo’s torn ACL in 2018 and his high ankle sprain in 2020.
Both injuries derailed the team’s hopes of contending for a Super Bowl title.
The team’s bad luck continued this season, when Garoppolo suffered a calf injury in Week 4 against the Seattle Seahawks. The injury forced rookie Trey Lance to make his first NFL start in Week 5 against the Arizona Cardinals.
Lance showed some flashes of potential, but also struggled with accuracy and decision-making. He also injured his knee in the game and is expected to miss at least one week.
The 49ers are now left with two healthy quarterbacks on their roster: Nate Sudfeld and Josh Rosen. Sudfeld has never started an NFL game and has thrown only 37 passes in his career.
Rosen was signed off the Atlanta Falcons’ practice squad last week and has not played since 2019. He has a career record of 3-13 as a starter and a passer rating of 63.5.
The 49ers are hoping that Garoppolo or Lance can return soon and stabilize the QB position. But given their history of injuries and inconsistency, some fans and analysts are wondering if the team is jinxed at the most important position in football.
Is there a curse on the 49ers’ quarterbacks? Or is it just a coincidence that they have been plagued by misfortune? The answer may not be clear, but one thing is certain: the team needs to find a reliable and durable QB if they want to compete for championships again.
Final Thoughts: Is There a Curse on the San Francisco 49ers’ Quarterbacks?
The San Francisco 49ers’ recent struggles at the quarterback position are certainly noteworthy, with multiple injuries and inconsistent play from various players over the past few years.
However, it’s difficult to definitively say whether or not there is a curse on the team’s quarterbacks.
Injuries are a common occurrence in the NFL, and some teams seem to be more prone to them than others. The 49ers have had their fair share of bad luck in this regard, with Garoppolo’s ACL tear in 2018 and subsequent injuries being particularly devastating.
However, it’s worth noting that many of the team’s other QB injuries have been more minor, such as high ankle sprains, which are a common injury in football.
In terms of inconsistent play, it’s hard to say whether this is due to bad luck or other factors. Some of the quarterbacks who have struggled with the 49ers, such as Brian Hoyer and Nick Mullens, were never expected to be long-term solutions for the team.
Garoppolo has shown flashes of greatness, but has also had his fair share of struggles with turnovers and accuracy. Trey Lance is a promising rookie, but still has a lot to learn and develop.
It’s also worth noting that the 49ers have had success with quarterbacks in the past, with legends like Joe Montana and Steve Young leading the team to multiple Super Bowl titles.
This suggests that any curse or bad luck is a relatively recent phenomenon, rather than a longstanding issue with the team.
Overall, while it’s easy to see why some fans and analysts might believe in a curse on the 49ers’ quarterbacks, it’s more likely that the team has simply been unlucky in recent years.
Injuries are an unfortunate part of football, and finding a reliable and durable QB is a challenge for many teams in the league. If the 49ers can stay healthy and find a consistent signal-caller, there’s no reason they can’t compete for championships again in the future.