Chris Simms, a former NFL quarterback and current NBC Sports analyst, is no stranger to controversy. He often makes bold and unconventional claims about players, teams and coaches, sometimes drawing criticism from fans and experts alike. His latest take, however, might be one of his most bizarre and unpopular yet.
On his podcast “Chris Simms Unbuttoned”, Simms ranked the top 40 quarterbacks in the NFL heading into the 2023 season. While some of his choices were reasonable and expected, such as Patrick Mahomes at number one and Aaron Rodgers at number two, others were downright shocking and questionable.
For example, he placed Tom Brady, the seven-time Super Bowl champion and reigning MVP, at number 10, behind younger and less accomplished passers like Justin Herbert, Joe Burrow and Kyler Murray. He also ranked Dak Prescott, who led the league in passing yards and touchdowns in 2022, at number 18, behind rookies like Trevor Lawrence and Zach Wilson.
But perhaps his most outrageous and controversial ranking was putting Taysom Hill, the versatile backup for the New Orleans Saints, at number 24, ahead of proven starters like Kirk Cousins, Ryan Tannehill and Derek Carr.
Simms praised Hill for his athleticism, arm strength and leadership, while dismissing his lack of experience, accuracy and consistency as a passer. He argued that Hill has the potential to be a dynamic dual-threat quarterback in the mold of Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen, if given the opportunity to start full-time.
Simms’ ranking of Hill sparked a lot of backlash and ridicule from the NFL world, especially on social media. Many fans and analysts mocked Simms for his apparent bias towards Hill, who he has been hyping up for years.
Some accused him of trolling or seeking attention with his hot takes. Others questioned his credibility and sanity as an evaluator of talent. Here are some of the reactions to Simms’ latest bizarre take:
- “Chris Simms has Taysom Hill ranked higher than Kirk Cousins, Ryan Tannehill and Derek Carr. This is why we can’t have nice things.” – @NFL_Memes
- “Chris Simms is either a genius or a madman. There is no in between.” – @PatMcAfeeShow
- “Chris Simms ranking Taysom Hill ahead of actual quarterbacks is an insult to the game of football.” – @AdamSchein
- “Chris Simms must have hit his head too hard when he played in the NFL. How else can you explain his ridiculous rankings?” – @ColinCowherd
- “Chris Simms is living in a fantasy world where Taysom Hill is a top 25 quarterback. Wake up, buddy.” – @DanOrlovsky7
Simms has not backed down from his ranking of Hill, despite the overwhelming criticism. He defended his opinion on Twitter, saying that he trusts his eyes and film study more than stats or popularity.
He also challenged his detractors to watch more tape of Hill and see what he sees. He claimed that he is not afraid to go against the grain and speak his mind, even if it means being unpopular or misunderstood.
Whether Simms is right or wrong about Hill remains to be seen. Hill has only started four games in his career, winning three of them. He has thrown for 928 yards, four touchdowns and two interceptions, while rushing for 457 yards and eight touchdowns.
He is currently competing with Jameis Winston for the starting job in New Orleans, following Drew Brees’ retirement. If he wins the job and performs well in 2023, Simms might look like a visionary. If he loses the job or struggles as a passer, Simms might look like a fool.
One thing is certain: Simms will continue to make headlines with his hot takes, whether people agree with him or not.
Final Thoughts: Chris Simms’ Controversial Ranking of Taysom Hill
Chris Simms, a former NFL quarterback and current NBC Sports analyst, has caused a stir in the NFL world with his latest ranking of the top 40 quarterbacks heading into the 2023 season. While some of his choices were understandable, such as putting Patrick Mahomes and Aaron Rodgers at the top, others were eyebrow-raising and controversial.
Simms placed Taysom Hill, the backup quarterback for the New Orleans Saints, at number 24, ahead of several established starters like Kirk Cousins, Ryan Tannehill, and Derek Carr.
Simms justified his ranking by praising Hill’s athleticism, arm strength, and leadership qualities, while downplaying his lack of experience, accuracy, and consistency as a passer. He argued that Hill has the potential to be a dynamic dual-threat quarterback in the mold of Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen, if given the opportunity to start full-time.
However, Simms’ ranking of Hill has been widely criticized and ridiculed by fans and experts alike. Many have accused Simms of being biased towards Hill, who he has been hyping up for years. Some have even questioned his sanity and credibility as an evaluator of talent.
In my opinion, Simms’ ranking of Hill is overly optimistic and premature. While Hill has shown flashes of potential as a runner and passer in limited action, he has yet to prove himself as a full-time starter in the NFL.
His lack of experience, accuracy, and consistency are major red flags that cannot be ignored. Moreover, his age (32) and injury history make it unlikely that he will suddenly develop into an elite quarterback.
That being said, I appreciate Simms’ willingness to go against the conventional wisdom and speak his mind. As a former player and analyst, he has a unique perspective on the game and is entitled to his own opinions. However, he should be prepared to face criticism and skepticism when he makes bold and unconventional claims.
While Taysom Hill may have the potential to be a dynamic quarterback in the future, his current ranking as a top-25 quarterback by Chris Simms is unwarranted and premature. Only time will tell if Hill can prove his doubters wrong and become a star in the league.