Is Pujols the Best Hitter?

Frank Jones

Is Pujols the Best Hitter

Baseball is a sport that is full of debates, and one of the most contentious is the question of who is the best hitter since Hank Aaron and Willie Mays retired in the mid-1970s.

Many legendary players have graced the diamond since then, but one name that often comes up in this discussion is Albert Pujols.

With an impressive track record that includes three NL MVP awards and 10 top-five finishes, Pujols has certainly made his mark on the game.

In this blog post, we will explore whether or not Pujols is the best hitter since Aaron and Mays retired, looking at his career statistics, comparing him to other great hitters of the modern era, and discussing the subjective nature of this debate.

Pujols’ Career Statistics

Albert Pujols has had a remarkable career, spanning over two decades. He has played for three different teams, including the St. Louis Cardinals, Los Angeles Angels, and the Los Angeles Dodgers.

Pujols has amassed impressive statistics throughout his career, including a batting average of .299, an on-base percentage of .376, and a slugging percentage of .548. He has hit a total of 677 home runs, with 3,301 hits, 2,112 RBIs, and 1,859 runs scored.

Pujols has also earned several accolades throughout his career, including three National League MVP awards, two Gold Gloves, and ten Silver Slugger awards. He has been selected to the All-Star team ten times and has won two batting titles.

When compared to other great hitters in baseball history, Pujols’ statistics hold up well. He is one of only nine players in Major League Baseball history to reach 3,000 hits and 600 home runs, putting him in rare company.

His career OPS+ (adjusted on-base plus slugging percentage) of 147 is among the highest in baseball history, placing him in the same company as other legendary hitters like Babe Ruth, Ted Williams, and Barry Bonds.

While Pujols’ career statistics are certainly impressive, it’s worth noting that there are other legendary hitters in baseball history with even more impressive numbers. For example, Hank Aaron hit 755 home runs and has more career RBIs and total bases than Pujols.

Babe Ruth had a career OPS+ of 207, which is significantly higher than Pujols’. Nonetheless, Pujols’ career statistics and achievements put him among the all-time great hitters in baseball history.

Other Legendary Hitters of the Modern Era

Barry Bonds is one of the most legendary hitters of the modern era, but his career is marred by allegations of performance-enhancing drug use. Nonetheless, his career statistics are impressive, with a career OPS+ of 182, 762 home runs, and a .444 on-base percentage.

Miguel Cabrera is another player who is often mentioned in discussions of the best hitters of his generation. Cabrera has a career batting average of .313, an OPS+ of 152, 2,955 hits, and 498 home runs.

Mike Trout is considered by many to be the best all-around player in baseball today, but he is also a phenomenal hitter. He has a career OPS+ of 177, a batting average of .304, and 310 home runs. Despite being just 30 years old, Trout is already considered one of the greatest players of all time.

Alex Rodriguez, like Bonds, has faced allegations of performance-enhancing drug use, but his career statistics are still impressive. He has a career OPS+ of 140, 696 home runs, and a .382 on-base percentage.

When compared to these other legendary hitters, Pujols holds his own. His career OPS+ is higher than all but Bonds, and his home run total is second only to Bonds. While Cabrera and Trout have higher batting averages, Pujols has been a more consistent hitter over a longer period of time.

Rodriguez has hit more home runs, but Pujols has been a more complete hitter with better on-base and slugging percentages. Overall, while these players all have impressive resumes, Pujols is certainly among the best hitters of his generation.

Factors to Consider

When evaluating a hitter’s performance and impact on the game, there are several factors to consider. Here are a few:

Batting Average

Batting average is a measure of how often a hitter gets a hit relative to their total at-bats. While a high batting average is certainly impressive, it doesn’t tell the whole story. A hitter’s ability to get on base through walks or hit by pitches is also important.

On-base Percentage

On-base percentage (OBP) is a more comprehensive measure of a hitter’s ability to get on base. It includes not just hits, but also walks and hit by pitches. A high OBP means that a hitter is skilled at avoiding outs and keeping the inning alive.

Slugging Percentage

Slugging percentage measures a hitter’s ability to hit for extra bases, including doubles, triples, and home runs.

It’s calculated by dividing the total number of bases a hitter has by their total number of at-bats. A high slugging percentage means that a hitter is able to hit the ball with power.


OPS+ is a statistic that adjusts a hitter’s OPS (on-base plus slugging percentage) for the league and ballpark in which they played. A score of 100 is considered average, and anything above that indicates an above-average hitter.

When evaluating Pujols and other legendary hitters in these factors, it’s clear that they all have their strengths. Pujols has a high career OPS+ and a solid slugging percentage, while Cabrera has a high batting average and impressive power numbers.

Bonds has an otherworldly on-base percentage and power numbers, while Trout has a high OPS+ and a well-rounded skill set.

Overall, while each of these legendary hitters has their own strengths, it’s difficult to say definitively who is the best. The subjective nature of evaluating hitters means that it ultimately comes down to personal opinion.

However, it’s clear that Pujols is among the greatest hitters of his generation and has had a significant impact on the game of baseball.

Subjectivity of the Debate

It’s important to acknowledge the subjective nature of the debate over who the best hitter since Aaron and Mays retired is. Personal biases and opinions can shape one’s perception of a player’s greatness, and there are several factors that can influence these biases.

One factor is a person’s age and the era in which they grew up. Someone who grew up watching Hank Aaron or Willie Mays may have a different opinion on who the best hitter since their retirement is than someone who grew up watching Albert Pujols or Barry Bonds.

Another factor is a person’s team allegiance. Fans of a particular team may have a bias towards players on their favorite team, while fans of rival teams may have a bias against those same players.

Media coverage and narrative can also shape one’s perception of a player’s greatness. For example, if a player is consistently hyped up by the media, it can influence how people perceive their accomplishments and impact on the game.

Finally, personal biases towards certain statistics or styles of play can also shape one’s opinion. Some people may place a higher value on batting average or on-base percentage, while others may prioritize power numbers like home runs and slugging percentage.

Overall, it’s important to recognize the subjectivity of this debate and to approach it with an open mind. While statistical analysis can provide some objective data to support arguments, personal biases and opinions will always play a role in shaping one’s perception of a player’s greatness.

Career statistics of Albert Pujols, Barry Bonds, Miguel Cabrera, Mike Trout, and Alex Rodriguez:

PlayerGames PlayedBatting AverageHome RunsRBIOPS+MVP Awards
Albert Pujols2,952.2996792,1121423
Barry Bonds2,986.2987621,9961827
Miguel Cabrera2,646.3114871,7481522
Mike Trout1,194.3053107841783
Alex Rodriguez2,784.2956962,0861403

The table shows that all five players have had incredible careers, with impressive statistics and numerous accolades.

It’s important to note that these statistics don’t tell the full story of a player’s impact on the game, but they do provide a useful starting point for comparing their greatness as hitters.

Frequently Asked Questions

How has the changing landscape of baseball impacted the debate over the best hitter since Aaron and Mays retired?

The changing landscape of baseball, including changes in pitching strategies, the introduction of advanced statistics, and the increased focus on player health and longevity, has impacted how players are evaluated as hitters. This, in turn, has impacted the debate over who the best hitter since Aaron and Mays retired is.

What role does a player’s defensive ability play in the debate over their hitting greatness?

While the debate over the best hitter since Aaron and Mays retired is primarily focused on offensive statistics, a player’s defensive ability can also play a role in their overall impact on the game. However, it is not typically a major factor in determining their hitting greatness.

Are there any non-statistical factors that should be considered when evaluating a player’s hitting greatness?

Yes, there are several non-statistical factors that can impact a player’s hitting greatness, including their impact on the game and their ability to perform in clutch situations. However, these factors can be difficult to measure objectively and are often subject to personal biases and opinions.

Can a player’s off-field conduct impact their perceived hitting greatness?

Yes, a player’s off-field conduct can impact how they are perceived as a hitter and as a player in general. For example, Barry Bonds’ alleged involvement with performance-enhancing drugs has led some to question the legitimacy of his impressive career statistics.

Are there any players currently playing who could eventually be considered among the best hitters since Aaron and Mays retired?

It’s possible. Players like Mike Trout, Bryce Harper, and Shohei Ohtani are all currently playing at an extremely high level and could potentially be considered among the best hitters of their generation by the end of their careers. However, it’s still too early to tell for sure.

To Recap

The debate over who the best hitter since Hank Aaron and Willie Mays retired is a highly subjective one. While players like Albert Pujols, Barry Bonds, Miguel Cabrera, Mike Trout, and Alex Rodriguez are all considered among the greatest hitters in baseball history, personal biases and opinions can shape one’s perception of their greatness.

Factors like age, team allegiance, media coverage, and personal biases towards certain statistics can all influence one’s opinion. It’s important to approach this debate with an open mind and to recognize that there is no clear-cut answer.

That being said, it’s clear that Albert Pujols is among the greatest hitters of his generation and has had a significant impact on the game of baseball.

His impressive career statistics and numerous accolades speak for themselves, and he will undoubtedly be remembered as one of the all-time greats.

Leave a Comment