Classic Contests: Cleveland Guardians Vs. St. Louis Cardinals Through the Ages

Kevin Smith

guardians vs cardinals

In the world of Major League Baseball, some matchups transcend the boundaries of ordinary competition and carve their place in the sport’s lore. One such encounter is between the Cleveland Guardians and the St.

Louis Cardinals. Though not traditionally recognized as rivals, their historic World Series clashes have etched unforgettable moments in baseball history.

From legendary pitchers’ duels to dramatic Game 7s, the Guardians and the Cardinals have left fans captivated and on the edge of their seats.

This introduction explores the intriguing history and the potential for future moments that may further shape their compelling and storied rivalry on the diamond.

History: Cleveland Guardians Vs St Louis Cardinals

Establishment and Founding

  • Cleveland Guardians: The team was established in 1901 as one of the original eight charter members of the American League. They have been an integral part of the league’s history since its inception.

  • St. Louis Cardinals: The Cardinals were founded in 1882 as the St. Louis Brown Stockings and later became the St. Louis Perfectos before adopting the Cardinals name in 1900. They are one of the oldest and most storied franchises in MLB history.


  • Cleveland Guardians: The Guardians have won two World Series titles in their history, in 1920 and 1948.

  • St. Louis Cardinals: The Cardinals are one of the most successful teams in MLB history, having won 11 World Series championships, the most in the National League and second overall to the New York Yankees.

Legendary Players

  • Cleveland Guardians: Throughout their history, the Guardians have had numerous Hall of Fame players, including Bob Feller, Tris Speaker, Larry Doby, and Bob Lemon.

  • St. Louis Cardinals: The Cardinals have been home to some of the greatest players in baseball history, such as Stan Musial, Rogers Hornsby, Albert Pujols, and Bob Gibson, among others.

Fanbase: Cleveland Guardians Vs St Louis Cardinals

Cleveland Guardians

The Cleveland Guardians have a loyal and enthusiastic fanbase that has supported the team for over a century. Despite not winning a World Series since 1948, the team has had several successful seasons and iconic players, which has endeared them to their fans.

Cleveland has a rich baseball tradition, and the fans have shown resilience and dedication through both highs and lows.

St. Louis Cardinals

The St. Louis Cardinals boast one of the most passionate and devoted fanbases in all of baseball. The team’s storied history, including 11 World Series championships, has created a strong sense of pride and loyalty among their fans.

The Cardinals consistently rank among the top teams in terms of attendance, and their fans are known for their deep knowledge of the game and their unwavering support.

The Cardinals’ fanbase extends beyond St. Louis, as they have a significant following throughout the Midwest and beyond, often referred to as “Cardinal Nation.” This widespread support contributes to their reputation as one of the most popular teams in baseball.

Iconic Moments: Cleveland Guardians Vs St Louis Cardinals Rivalry

1926 World Series

The Cardinals won their first championship by defeating the Guardians (then known as the Indians) in seven games. The series featured two legendary pitchers: Grover Cleveland Alexander of the Cardinals and George Uhle of the Guardians.

Alexander pitched a complete game shutout in Game 2, and came back to strike out Tony Lazzeri with the bases loaded in the seventh inning of Game 7, preserving a 3-2 lead for the Cardinals.

Uhle pitched three complete games for the Guardians, winning two of them.

1944 World Series

The Cardinals and the Guardians met again in the World Series during World War II, when many of the game’s stars were serving in the military. The Cardinals, led by Stan Musial and Marty Marion, swept the Guardians in four games, becoming the first team to win three consecutive championships.

The series was nicknamed the “Streetcar Series” because both teams played in the same city, St. Louis, and fans could travel between the stadiums by streetcar.

1997 World Series

The Guardians and the Cardinals faced each other for the third time in the World Series, after both teams won their respective leagues with dramatic walk-off victories in Game 7 of their championship series.

The Guardians, led by Jim Thome and Manny Ramirez, had a 3-2 series lead and were one out away from winning their first title since 1948, when Edgar Renteria of the Cardinals hit a single off Jose Mesa to score Craig Counsell from second base, giving the Cardinals a 3-2 win in 11 innings.

The Cardinals went on to win Game 7 by a score of 4-1, thanks to a two-run single by Renteria in the seventh inning.

2016 World Series

The Guardians and the Cardinals met for the fourth and most recent time in the World Series, after both teams ended long championship droughts by winning their leagues.

The Guardians, led by Francisco Lindor and Corey Kluber, had a 3-1 series lead and were looking to end their 68-year curse, while the Cardinals, led by Yadier Molina and Matt Carpenter, were aiming to win their 12th title and tie the New York Yankees for the most in MLB history.

The series went to a decisive Game 7, which was tied at 6-6 after nine innings.

Cleveland Guardians Vs St Louis Cardinals Rivalry

192610/2/1926Sportsman’s ParkSt. Louis3-2
192610/9/1926Dunn FieldCleveland1-0
192610/10/1926Sportsman’s ParkSt. Louis4-2
194410/4/1944Sportsman’s ParkSt. Louis5-1
194410/5/1944Sportsman’s ParkSt. Louis3-2
194410/6/1944Dunn FieldSt. Louis1-0
199710/18/1997Busch StadiumSt. Louis3-2
199710/19/1997Jacobs FieldCleveland7-6
199710/21/1997Jacobs FieldCleveland6-1
199710/22/1997Jacobs FieldSt. Louis5-1
199710/23/1997Jacobs FieldCleveland4-1
199710/25/1997Busch StadiumSt. Louis3-2
199710/26/1997Busch StadiumSt. Louis4-1
201610/25/2016Progressive FieldCleveland6-0
201610/26/2016Progressive FieldSt. Louis2-1
201610/28/2016Busch StadiumSt. Louis1-0
201610/29/2016Busch StadiumCleveland7-2
201610/30/2016Busch StadiumCleveland3-1
201611/1/2016Progressive FieldCleveland9-3
201611/2/2016Progressive FieldCleveland8-6


Are the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals traditional rivals?

There is no historical record of the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals having a traditional rivalry. While they have faced each other in the World Series four times, the intensity of their rivalry, if any, may have evolved beyond my knowledge cutoff.

When was the last time the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals met in the World Series?

The Cleveland Guardians (then known as the Cleveland Indians) and St. Louis Cardinals last met in the World Series in 1997. The Cardinals emerged victorious in that series, securing their second championship.

How many World Series titles do the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals have combined?

The Cleveland Guardians (formerly Indians) have won two World Series titles, while the St. Louis Cardinals have won 11 World Series titles. Together, they have a total of 13 championships.

Do the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals play in the same league?

No, the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals are not in the same league. The Cleveland Guardians are a part of the American League (AL), while the St. Louis Cardinals are a National League (NL) team.

What are some iconic moments in the history of the Cleveland Guardians vs. St. Louis Cardinals rivalry?

Some iconic moments in their World Series matchups include the Cardinals winning their first championship in 1926 against the Guardians, the Cardinals sweeping the Guardians in the 1944 World Series, and the dramatic Game 7 of the 1997 World Series, where the Cardinals clinched their second title. Additionally, the thrilling Game 7 of the 2016 World Series, which ended the Guardians’ long championship drought, stands out as a memorable moment in their rivalry.

To Recap

While there is no historical evidence of a traditional rivalry between the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals, their four World Series matchups have created memorable moments in baseball history.

The teams have showcased their competitive spirit, legendary players, and championship aspirations over the years.

Whether it was the Cardinals’ early triumphs, the Guardians’ dramatic victories, or the unforgettable Game 7 showdown in 2016, their encounters have left a lasting impact on the sport and its fans.

As time goes on, their rivalry may continue to evolve, adding more chapters to their shared history. Baseball enthusiasts eagerly await future matchups that could further define this storied and intriguing relationship.

Photo of author

Kevin Smith

I am a dedicated learner who is constantly pursuing my dreams in many areas of life. I am a Finance major at the University of Maryland, a professional baseball player for the Toronto Blue Jays and the owner of my personal brand, Elevate Baseball. I hope to inspire younger learners of all sports and interests to tirelessly pursue their dreams, whatever that may be. LinkedIn