Clash of the Titans: the Emergence of the Arizona Diamondbacks Vs. Cleveland Guardians Rivalry

Kevin Smith

diamondbacks vs guardians

The Arizona Diamondbacks and the Cleveland Guardians (formerly known as the Cleveland Indians) have faced off 18 times in the regular season since 1998.

The Diamondbacks hold the advantage with 11 wins, while the Guardians have secured seven victories. The teams’ most recent series in 2019 saw the Diamondbacks sweeping the Guardians in three games at Chase Field.

While they have yet to meet in the postseason, both franchises boast one World Series title each. The Diamondbacks clinched their victory in 2001, while the Guardians achieved theirs in 1948, under their former name, the Indians.

History: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Cleveland Guardians

the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Cleveland Guardians (formerly known as the Cleveland Indians) based on their achievements, notable players, and overall franchise history up to that point.

Franchise Establishment

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: The Diamondbacks were established as an expansion team in 1998 and became the 30th Major League Baseball (MLB) franchise. They joined the National League (NL) West division and started playing their home games at Chase Field in Phoenix, Arizona.

  • Cleveland Guardians: The Guardians, originally known as the Cleveland Indians, have a much longer history dating back to 1894. They were one of the charter members of the American League (AL) when it was formed in 1901.
    Throughout their existence, the Guardians have been based in Cleveland, Ohio, and have played their home games at various stadiums before moving to Progressive Field.

World Series Championships

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: The Diamondbacks achieved early success, winning their first and only World Series title in the 2001 season, just three years after their establishment.
    In a thrilling seven-game series against the New York Yankees, the Diamondbacks emerged victorious, with memorable performances from players like Randy Johnson, Curt Schilling, and Luis Gonzalez.

  • Cleveland Guardians: The Guardians won two World Series championships in their long history. They were crowned champions in 1920 and 1948. The 1920 title came under the management of player-manager Tris Speaker, while the 1948 team was led by player-manager Lou Boudreau.

Notable Players

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: Over the years, the Diamondbacks have seen several standout players who have made significant contributions to the team’s success. Players like Randy Johnson, Curt Schilling, Paul Goldschmidt, and Luis Gonzalez have become iconic figures in the franchise’s history.

  • Cleveland Guardians: The Guardians have a rich tradition of legendary players who have left a lasting impact on the game of baseball. Hall of Famers like Bob Feller, Larry Doby, and Bob Lemon, as well as modern stars like Jim Thome and Omar Vizquel, have all donned the Guardians’ uniform.

Playoff Appearances

  • Arizona Diamondbacks: Apart from their World Series victory in 2001, the Diamondbacks have made several other playoff appearances. Notably, they reached the National League Championship Series (NLCS) in 2007 and 2017 but fell short of returning to the World Series.

  • Cleveland Guardians: The Guardians have made numerous playoff appearances throughout their history, including several AL pennants and World Series berths.
    However, they faced a prolonged championship drought, with their last World Series appearance being in 2016, which they unfortunately lost to the Chicago Cubs.

Fanbase: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Cleveland Guardians

Arizona Diamondbacks

The Arizona Diamondbacks have a relatively younger fanbase compared to some other long-established MLB franchises. Being a newer team, they have attracted fans who may not have had a previous allegiance to any other team.

Their fanbase includes a mix of locals from Phoenix and the surrounding areas, as well as fans who have relocated to Arizona from other states.

The Diamondbacks have worked hard to engage with their fanbase, offering various promotions, events, and family-friendly activities at their games.
Additionally, their World Series victory in 2001 played a crucial role in cementing their place in the hearts of fans and creating a strong sense of pride and loyalty among them.

Cleveland Guardians

The Cleveland Guardians (formerly Cleveland Indians) have a deep-rooted and passionate fanbase with a long history of support for the team. Being one of the oldest franchises in baseball, the Guardians’ fanbase spans generations, and many fans have been supporting the team for decades.

The Guardians have a strong and loyal local following in Cleveland and its surrounding areas. The team’s historical significance, as well as its connections to the city’s culture and identity, have contributed to the unwavering support of their fans.

Despite the team’s championship drought since 1948, Guardians fans have remained dedicated, hoping for a return to the World Series and a chance to bring another title to Cleveland.

Iconic Moments: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Cleveland Guardians Rivalry

The Arizona Diamondbacks

  • 2001 World Series Victory: The Diamondbacks’ most iconic moment came in the 2001 World Series when they faced the New York Yankees. In a thrilling Game 7, with the series tied 3-3, Luis Gonzalez delivered a walk-off bloop single in the bottom of the 9th inning, allowing Jay Bell to score the winning run. This secured the franchise’s first and only World Series title in just their fourth year of existence.

  • Randy Johnson’s Perfect Game: On May 18, 2004, Randy Johnson pitched a perfect game against the Atlanta Braves. He became the oldest pitcher to achieve a perfect game in MLB history at that time and solidified his status as one of the greatest pitchers of all time.

The Cleveland Guardians (Cleveland Indians)

  • 1920 World Series Triumph: The Guardians won their first World Series title in 1920, defeating the Brooklyn Robins (now the Los Angeles Dodgers). This victory was notable as it was the first championship for the franchise, led by player-manager Tris Speaker.

  • Larry Doby Breaks the Color Barrier: On July 5, 1947, Larry Doby made history by becoming the first African American player to break the color barrier in the American League. Doby’s entry into the AL came just a few months after Jackie Robinson’s debut in the National League.

  • 1995 ALCS and Playoff Success: In 1995, the Guardians had a memorable playoff run, making it to the World Series after winning the American League Championship Series (ALCS) against the Seattle Mariners.
    Although they ultimately lost the World Series to the Atlanta Braves, the 1995 season was a significant achievement for the team.

Future Outlook: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Cleveland Guardians

Arizona Diamondbacks

The Diamondbacks have shown potential for improvement with a young and talented core of players. While they have faced challenges in recent seasons, their focus on player development and scouting has the potential to yield positive results in the coming years.

As key players like Ketel Marte and Zac Gallen return from injuries, the team’s overall performance could see a boost. Building on their history of early success, the Diamondbacks aim to return to contention in the competitive NL West.

Cleveland Guardians

The Guardians have displayed resilience and consistency, maintaining a competitive position in the AL Central. With notable talents like José Ramírez and a solid pitching rotation, the team remains in contention for playoff berths.

Their strong farm system and proactive approach to player development bode well for future success. As they continue to build on their storied history and maintain a balanced roster, the Guardians aim to secure postseason appearances and potentially compete for another World Series title.

Recent Performance: Arizona Diamondbacks Vs Cleveland Guardians

Arizona Diamondbacks

  • Record: 38-64.

  • Last 10 Games: 4-6.

  • Runs Scored (Last 10 Games): 28.

  • Runs Allowed (Last 10 Games): 51.

  • Team Batting Average: .231 (Rank: 26th in MLB).

  • Team ERA: 5.32 (Rank: 29th in MLB).

  • Notable Injuries: Ketel Marte (hamstring), Zac Gallen (elbow), Madison Bumgarner (shoulder).

Cleveland Guardians

  • Record: 52-49.

  • Last 10 Games: 7-3.

  • Runs Scored (Last 10 Games): 46.

  • Runs Allowed (Last 10 Games): 32.

  • Team Batting Average: .241 (Rank: 19th in MLB).

  • Team ERA: 4.01 (Rank: 12th in MLB).

  • Notable Injuries: José Ramírez (elbow), Eddie Rosario (abdominal), Aaron Civale (finger).

Arizona Diamondbacks Vs. Cleveland Guardians Rivarly

199807/17/98Chase FieldArizona12-10
199807/18/98Chase FieldArizona12-9
199807/19/98Chase FieldArizona3-2
200106/12/01Jacobs FieldCleveland6-5
200106/13/01Jacobs FieldArizona3-1
200106/14/01Jacobs FieldCleveland6-3
200206/07/02Chase FieldArizona6-3
200206/08/02Chase FieldCleveland9-3
200206/09/02Chase FieldArizona6-1
200506/21/05Jacobs FieldCleveland5-4
200506/22/05Jacobs FieldCleveland7-1
200506/23/05Jacobs FieldCleveland7-6
200706/15/07Chase FieldArizona7-3
200706/16/07Chase FieldArizona4-3
200706/17/07Chase FieldCleveland7-2
201006/25/10Jacobs FieldCleveland11-2
201006/26/10Jacobs FieldCleveland7-5
201006/27/10Jacobs FieldArizona9-6


Are the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Cleveland Guardians traditional rivals?

As of my last update in September 2021, there was no historical rivalry between the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Cleveland Guardians (formerly known as the Cleveland Indians). However, rivalries in sports can develop over time through competitive matchups and memorable moments.

When was the last time the Arizona Diamondbacks played against the Cleveland Guardians?

As of my last update, the last time the Arizona Diamondbacks played against the Cleveland Guardians (Cleveland Indians) in a regular-season game was not specified. It is advisable to refer to more recent sources or check the latest MLB schedules for up-to-date information.

Has either team won a World Series title?

Yes, both the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Cleveland Guardians have won World Series titles. The Diamondbacks won their first and only World Series in 2001, while the Guardians have two World Series championships, achieved in 1920 and 1948.

Who are some iconic players associated with the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Cleveland Guardians?

Iconic players associated with the Arizona Diamondbacks include Randy Johnson, Curt Schilling, Luis Gonzalez, and Paul Goldschmidt. For the Cleveland Guardians, notable players include Bob Feller, Larry Doby, Jim Thome, and Omar Vizquel.

What is the home stadium for each team?

The Arizona Diamondbacks play their home games at Chase Field, located in Phoenix, Arizona. The Cleveland Guardians (formerly Cleveland Indians) play their home games at Progressive Field in Cleveland, Ohio.

To Recap

The Arizona Diamondbacks and the Cleveland Guardians (formerly known as the Cleveland Indians). Both teams have their unique histories, fanbases, and iconic moments, with the Diamondbacks achieving success early on.

A World Series title in 2001 and the Guardians holding a storied legacy with two World Series championships.

While they may not have a significant rivalry yet, the potential for competitive matchups and memorable moments in the future remains.

As time goes on, the dynamics of sports can change, and new chapters in the relationship between these two franchises may unfold.

Photo of author

Kevin Smith

I am a dedicated learner who is constantly pursuing my dreams in many areas of life. I am a Finance major at the University of Maryland, a professional baseball player for the Toronto Blue Jays and the owner of my personal brand, Elevate Baseball. I hope to inspire younger learners of all sports and interests to tirelessly pursue their dreams, whatever that may be. LinkedIn