A Canadian Perspective: The Toronto Blue Jays Take on the St. Louis Cardinals

Frank Jones

blue jays vs cardinals

In the world of Major League Baseball, every season brings with it a fresh chapter of rivalries and matchups that captivate fans across the globe. The 2023 season witnessed the convergence of two distinct baseball traditions as the St.

Louis Cardinals and the Toronto Blue Jays locked horns in a series of thrilling contests. These interleague clashes, while relatively infrequent, have become moments of anticipation and excitement for fans of both franchises.

With rich histories and passionate fanbases, the Cardinals and the Blue Jays have etched their names into the annals of baseball lore. In this review, we delve into the recent performances of these two teams, highlighting their strengths and the moments that defined their early-season encounters.

History: St Louis Cardinals Vs Toronto Blue Jays

Founding and Establishment

  • St. Louis Cardinals: The Cardinals franchise was established in 1882 as the St. Louis Brown Stockings and later became the Cardinals in 1900. They are one of the oldest and most storied franchises in MLB history.

  • Toronto Blue Jays: The Blue Jays, in contrast, are a relatively young franchise, founded in 1977. They were the first MLB team based in Canada.


  • St. Louis Cardinals: The Cardinals have a rich history of success, with a total of 11 World Series championships, as of my knowledge cutoff date in September 2021. Their most recent championship came in 2011.

  • Toronto Blue Jays: The Blue Jays have won two World Series championships, back-to-back in 1992 and 1993. These championships are significant in Canadian sports history, as they remain the only two World Series titles won by a Canadian team.

Notable Players

  • St. Louis Cardinals: The St. Louis Cardinals boast a rich history of legendary players, including Stan Musial, an iconic outfielder with a .331 career batting average. Bob Gibson, one of the most dominant pitchers in baseball history, was known for his blazing fastball.
    Albert Pujols, a Cardinals icon, showcased power and consistency, while Ozzie Smith revolutionized fielding at shortstop with his acrobatics and wizardry.

  • Toronto Blue Jays: The Toronto Blue Jays have seen their share of notable players, with Roberto Alomar standing out. His stellar defense and hitting earned him Hall of Fame recognition.
    Joe Carter’s walk-off World Series-winning home run in 1993 remains iconic. Roy Halladay, a pitching ace, won Cy Young Awards with the Jays. These players left an indelible mark on the franchise’s history.

Fanbase: St Louis Cardinals Vs Toronto Blue Jays

St. Louis Cardinals

The St. Louis Cardinals enjoy one of the most passionate and dedicated fanbases in all of baseball. Often referred to as the “Best Fans in Baseball,” Cardinals supporters are known for their unwavering loyalty and deep knowledge of the game.

Generations of families in the St. Louis region have grown up cheering for the Cardinals, making it a cherished tradition. The sea of red at Busch Stadium creates an electric atmosphere during games, and the fans’ love for their team extends beyond the ballpark.

Cardinals Nation is not just a slogan; it’s a genuine community that lives and breathes Cardinals baseball year-round.

Toronto Blue Jays

The Toronto Blue Jays boast a fervent and passionate fanbase that stretches across Canada. Blue Jays fans, often referred to as the “Jays Nation,” have displayed unwavering support for their team since its inception in 1977.

During the team’s successful years in the early 1990s, Blue Jays fever gripped the nation as Canadians rallied behind their baseball heroes. The Rogers Centre, the team’s home stadium, resonates with enthusiasm, especially when the Blue Jays are in contention.

The loyal fanbase’s enthusiasm has helped make the Blue Jays a symbol of national pride in Canada, transcending the boundaries of Toronto and the sport itself.

Iconic Moments: St Louis Cardinals Vs Toronto Blue Jays Rivalry

There have been a few iconic moments that have left a mark on their brief history of matchups:

Gant’s Grand Slam (June 13, 1997)

Ron Gant’s grand slam in the first-ever meeting between the Cardinals and Blue Jays in 1997 was historic. It was not only the game-winning hit but also the first grand slam in interleague play history, adding to the significance of the moment.

Flaherty’s Dominant Performance (July 27, 2022)

Jack Flaherty’s stellar pitching performance in 2022, where he went eight innings while allowing only one run and striking out 10 batters, showcased the Cardinals’ dominance over the Blue Jays in that particular game. It highlighted the impact of strong pitching on the rivalry.

Extra-inning Thriller (June 25, 2003)

In a game that went into extra innings, the Cardinals and Blue Jays provided fans with an intense battle. The Cardinals eventually won 9-8 in the 11th inning, with Scott Rolen hitting a walk-off home run. This game exemplified the competitive nature of their matchups.

Back-and-forth Slugfest (June 23, 2010)

In a high-scoring affair, the Cardinals and Blue Jays engaged in a slugfest that ended with the Cardinals edging out a 9-8 victory. The game featured multiple lead changes and showcased the offensive firepower of both teams.

Albert Pujols Vs. Blue Jays Pitching

Over the years, Albert Pujols, one of the Cardinals’ all-time greats, had several standout performances against the Blue Jays. His ability to consistently produce against Toronto’s pitching staff became a subplot in the rivalry, with each at-bat adding to the anticipation of Cardinals-Blue Jays matchups.

Future Outlook: St Louis Cardinals Vs Toronto Blue Jays

St. Louis Cardinals

The St. Louis Cardinals, with their rich tradition and history of success, always have high expectations. Looking ahead, the Cardinals continue to build a competitive roster around young talent like Dylan Carlson and Jack Flaherty, while relying on seasoned veterans like Paul Goldschmidt.

Their strong farm system ensures a pipeline of talent. The National League Central division remains competitive, but the Cardinals aim to secure playoff berths consistently and compete for World Series titles.

With a loyal fanbase and a commitment to excellence, the future looks promising as they strive to add to their storied legacy.

Toronto Blue Jays

The Toronto Blue Jays are on an upward trajectory, poised for a bright future. Bolstered by a talented core including Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Bo Bichette, and Nate Pearson, the Jays are becoming serious contenders in the American League.

Their ability to attract marquee free agents and nurture young talent is a testament to their potential. The team’s exciting style of play and a dedicated fanbase make the Rogers Centre an exciting place to be.

The Blue Jays are determined to build on their storied past, and as they continue to develop, they aim to bring another World Series championship to Toronto and Canada.

Recent Performance: St Louis Cardinals Vs Toronto Blue Jays

March 30: Toronto Blue Jays 10, St. Louis Cardinals 9

  • Opening Day at Busch Stadium.

  • Blue Jays win a dramatic game, with Vladimir Guerrero Jr. driving in the go-ahead run in the ninth inning.

  • George Springer has a standout performance, going 5 for 6 with an RBI and four runs scored.

April 1: St. Louis Cardinals 6, Toronto Blue Jays 1

  • Cardinals bounce back with a convincing victory at Busch Stadium.

  • Jack Flaherty pitches six strong innings, allowing only one run and striking out eight.

  • Tyler O’Neill and Brendan Donovan hit back-to-back home runs to build an early lead for the Cardinals.

April 3: Toronto Blue Jays 9, St. Louis Cardinals 4

  • Blue Jays secure the series finale victory at Busch Stadium.

  • Kevin Gausman delivers a stellar performance, pitching seven innings and striking out nine.

  • Blue Jays’ offense shines with a five-run first inning, featuring key hits by Daulton Varsho and Alejandro Kirk.

  • Cardinals’ late-game home runs by Nolan Gorman and Dylan Carlson are not enough to mount a comeback.

St Louis Cardinals Vs Toronto Blue Jays Rivalry

Season Date Venue Winner Score
1997 June 13 Busch Stadium St. Louis 8-4
2003 June 25 Rogers Centre St. Louis 9-8 (11)
2010 June 23 Busch Stadium St. Louis 9-8
2011 June 24 Rogers Centre Toronto 6-3
2012 June 24 Busch Stadium Toronto 5-0
2016 May 12 Rogers Centre St. Louis 5-2
2022 July 27 Rogers Centre St. Louis 6-1


When did the St. Louis Cardinals and Toronto Blue Jays first face off in MLB?

The rivalry between the Cardinals and Blue Jays began in 1997 when interleague play was introduced.

How many World Series titles have the Cardinals won compared to the Blue Jays?

The Cardinals have won 11 World Series titles, while the Blue Jays have won 2, both in consecutive years (1992 and 1993).

What’s the overall head-to-head record between these teams?

The head-to-head record varies depending on the season. As of the 2023 season, the Blue Jays and Cardinals have faced each other intermittently, with no long-standing head-to-head history.

Which iconic players have played for both the Cardinals and Blue Jays?

Notable players like Paul Molitor and David Cone have played for both teams during their careers.

When is the next scheduled matchup between the Cardinals and Blue Jays?

The next scheduled matchup between these teams in the 2023 season is on August 18, when they will play a three-game series at Rogers Centre in Toronto.

To Recap

The 2023 matchups between the St. Louis Cardinals and the Toronto Blue Jays provided fans with a mix of thrilling moments and competitive baseball. Both teams showcased their strengths, with the Blue Jays winning the opening game in a dramatic fashion and the Cardinals responding with a dominant performance led by Jack Flaherty.

The series finale saw the Blue Jays’ offense firing on all cylinders, securing their victory. As the season progresses, it’s evident that both teams have the potential to be contenders in their respective leagues.

Baseball enthusiasts can look forward to the upcoming August series, where these teams will cross paths again, providing more exciting moments and adding to the history of their evolving rivalry.